{"text_format":"3","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":5,"sheets":["OVERALL","Criteria 1","Criteria 2","Criteria 3","Criteria 4"],"not_rendered":{"defined_names":1,"comments":1},"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"OVERALL","index":0,"n_rows":21,"n_cols":17,"rows_kept":21,"merged":[[1,1,4,14],[1,16,6,22],[5,1,6,1],[5,2,5,4],[5,5,5,7],[5,8,5,10],[5,11,5,13],[5,14,6,14],[20,1,20,13]]}
[]
[null,"EU REFORM BAROMETER MATRIX",{"$nulls":14},"Ranking legend:\n0-25 points: weak performance;\n26-50 points: limited performance;\n51-75 points: good performance;\n76-100 points: very good performance."]
[]
[]
[]
[null,"Institution","Criteria 1: Measure Complexity",null,null,"Criteria 2: Planing vs EU Obligations",null,null,"Criteria 3: Implementation Rate",null,null,"Criteria 4: EU Country report assessment",null,null,"FINAL SCORE (sum of points)"]
[null,null," Score","Weight (25%)","Points (Score x Weight)  "," Score","Weight (35%)","Points (Score x Weight)  "," Score","Weight (30%)","Points (Score x Weight)  ","Score","Weight (10%)","Points (Score x Weight)  "]
[null,"Ministry of Economy",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O19","v":10},2.5,{"$f":"C8*D8","v":25},{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D16","v":4},3.5,{"$f":"F8*G8","v":14},{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F18","v":5},3,{"$f":"I8*J8","v":15},{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C6","v":10},1,{"$f":"L8*M8","v":10},{"$f":"N8+K8+H8+E8","v":64}]
[null,"Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Infrastructure",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O57","v":9},2.5,22.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D96","v":5},3.5,17.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F57","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C10","v":0},1,0,64]
[null,"Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and Innovation",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O98","v":6},2.5,15,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D126","v":4},3.5,14,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F98","v":7},3,21,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C15","v":10},1,10,60]
[null,"Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Development",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O108","v":10},2.5,25,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D146","v":3},3.5,10.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F108","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C19","v":0},1,0,{"v":59.5,"d":"60"}]
[null,"Ministry of Internal Affairs",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O158","v":7},2.5,17.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D174","v":4},3.5,14,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F158","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C23","v":0},1,0,{"v":55.5,"d":"56"}]
[null,"Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O199","v":7},2.5,17.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D237","v":2},3.5,7,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F199","v":7},3,21,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C33","v":10},1,10,{"v":55.5,"d":"56"}]
[null,"Ministry of Justice",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O208","v":10},2.5,25,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D252","v":2},3.5,7,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F208","v":7},3,21,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C36","v":0},1,0,53]
[null,"Ministry of Finance, Labor and Transfers",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O249","v":7},2.5,17.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D297","v":4},3.5,14,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F249","v":7},3,21,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C43","v":0},1,0,{"v":52.5,"d":"53"}]
[null,"Ministry of Communities and Returns",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O256","v":3},2.5,7.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D303","v":4},3.5,14,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F256","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C46","v":0},1,0,{"v":45.5,"d":"46"}]
[null,"Ministry of Health",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O271","v":9},2.5,22.5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D316","v":2},3.5,7,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F271","v":5},3,15,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C49","v":0},1,0,{"v":44.5,"d":"45"}]
[null,"Office of the Prime Minister",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O291","v":6},2.5,15,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D329","v":0},3.5,0,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F291","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C53","v":0},1,0,39]
[null,"Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O298","v":8},2.5,20,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D338","v":2},3.5,7,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F298","v":3},3,9,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C57","v":0},1,0,36]
[null,"Ministry of Local Government Administration",{"$f":"'Criteria 1'!O309","v":2},2.5,5,{"$f":"'Criteria 2'!D349","v":0},3.5,0,{"$f":"'Criteria 3'!F309","v":8},3,24,{"$f":"'Criteria 4'!C60","v":0},1,0,29]
[null,"Government",{"$nulls":12},{"$f":"AVERAGE(O8:O20)","v":{"v":50.61538461538461,"d":"51"}}]

{"sheet":"Criteria 1","index":1,"n_rows":312,"n_cols":17,"rows_kept":312,"merged":[[0,0,0,14],[1,0,2,0],[1,1,2,1],[1,2,2,2],[1,3,2,3],[1,4,2,4],[1,5,1,14],[3,0,3,14],[3,16,14,17],[17,0,17,13],[18,0,18,13],[19,0,19,14],[55,0,55,13],[56,0,56,13],[57,0,57,14],[96,0,96,13],[97,0,97,13],[98,0,98,14],[106,0,106,13],[107,0,107,13],[108,0,108,14],[156,0,156,13],[157,0,157,13],[158,0,158,14],[197,0,197,13],[198,0,198,13],[199,0,199,14],[206,0,206,13],[207,0,207,13],[208,0,208,14],[247,0,247,13],[248,0,248,13],[249,0,249,14],[254,0,254,13],[255,0,255,13],[256,0,256,14],[269,0,269,13],[270,0,270,13],[271,0,271,14],[289,0,289,13],[290,0,290,13],[291,0,291,14],[296,0,296,13],[297,0,297,13],[298,0,298,14],[307,0,307,13],[308,0,308,13],[311,0,311,14]]}
["Criteria 1: Measure complexity\nMinistries plan variety of measures within National Program for European Integration and European Reform Agenda. In some cases, these measures are relevant, well planned, strategic, complex and financially prudent. In other cases, they are not. Purpose of this assessment is to differentiate between well planned and less well-planned EU measures, rewarding thus better performing ministries."]
["Institution","Priority/Chapter","Measures","Deadline","Reference","Criteria 1: Measure complexity"]
[{"$nulls":5},"Specific","Measurable","Reform","Resource intensity","Interinstitutional complexity","Levels of approval","SAA & ERA priority","Measure approximates Acquis","Political sensitivity","Total"]
["Ministry of Economy",{"$nulls":15},"SAA priority chapters:\n\n1. Chapter 1: Free Movement of Goods\n2. Chapter 3: Right of Establishment and Freedom to Provide Services\n3. Chapter 5: Public Procurement\n4. Chapter 6: Company Law\n5. Chapter 7: IntellectAIl Property Law\n6. Chapter 8: Competition Policy\n7. Chapter 12: Food Safety, Veterinary and Phytosanitary Policy\n8. Chapter 23: Judiciary and Fundamental Rights\n9. Chapter 24: Justice, Freedom and Security\n10. Public Administration Reform (PAR)"]
["ME",null,"The draft law on energy, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F5:N5)","v":8}]
["ME",null,"The draft law on the energy regulator, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"The draft law on renewable energy sources, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q4 2022)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"The Energy Strategy Implementation Program, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q2 2022)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ME",null,"Energy and Climate Plan 2021-2030, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ME",null,"Regulation for the new support scheme for BER","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"Designing the competitive scheme for BER","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ME",null,"Opening of the energy market for 35 kV and 10 kV voltage level consumers","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ME",null,"Completed-amended draft law on public enterprises, based on EU recommendations and good practices, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"Approved by-laws","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"Code of ethics and corporate governance of public enterprises, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["ME",null,"Digital Agenda for Kosovo 2030, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["ME",null,"Twenty (20) mobile network stacks, '5G ready', connected to fixed broadband infrastructure","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.92,"d":"92%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},10]
["Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Infrastructure"]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on Road Transport, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F21:N21)","v":6}]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","AI for checking the technical regularity of vehicles on the road, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F22:N22)","v":3}]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","The 2023-2025 action plan for the implementation of the 2023-2030 multimodal transport strategy, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,6]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","Concept document for railways, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","Koncept dokumenti për transportin e mallrave të rrezikshme, i miratAIr","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","The draft law to supplement and amend the Law on Strategic Environmental Assessment, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","The draft law for climate change, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","The draft law on the inspection in the field of environment, water, nature, spatial planning, construction and housing, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","AI for packaging and packaging waste, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,1,0,6]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","Strategy for Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development 2022-2030, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI/ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","Kosovo State Water Strategy 2023-2027 and Action Plan 2023-2025 for its implementation, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI/ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
[null,null,"Concept document for the water field, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F32:N32)","v":5}]
[null,null,"Concept document for the field of nature protection, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
[null,null,"Construction and demolition waste management plan, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI/ERA",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
[null,null,"Number of inspectors trained to control the implementation of environmental legislation","Q4 2023","NPEI/ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
[null,null,"The number of new nature areas (around 10), protected","Q4 2023","NPEI/ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Number of illegal landfills in municipalities identified and reduced","Q3 2023","NPEI/ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
[null,null,"The inventory of greenhouse gases for 2021, prepare","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,0,5]
[null,null,"The draft law on the protection of air from pollution, approved","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F39:N39)","v":7}]
[null,null,"The draft law on Kosovo's waters, approved","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
[null,null,"The draft law for waste, approved","Q2 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
[null,null,"The beginning of the drafting of the decarbonization strategy","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
[null,null,"Revised national air qAIlity plan, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Plan for waste management with VSM in the area of Prishtina, drafted","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Management plan for the Drini i Bardhë river basin, finalized","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Underground water monitoring network, operationalized","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","Municipal level training for the implementation of waste management legislation","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
[null,null,"Starting the implementation of projects for management of of hazardous waste: the facility for the temporary storage of hazardous waste, decommissioning of Kosovo A","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Transfer and recycling centers in Skenderaj, Klinë, Istog,\nNovobërdë, built","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"The beginning of the creation of the deposit return system for bottles, plastic\nand cans","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Supplement-amendment of Law no. 03/L-233 on the protection of nature","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
[null,null,"Monitoring and reporting on the state of protected areas and\nbiodiversity","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
[null,null,"The spatial plan for the national park \"Sharri\", approved ","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Spatial plan of the national park \"Bjeshket e Nemuna\", approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Creation of the online Environmental Information System","Q1 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.83,"d":"83%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},9]
["Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and Innovation"]
["MASHTI","Q3: E drejta e themelimit dhe liria e ofrimit të shërbimeve","AI for the completion-amendment of the AI for the Standards and Procedures of Verification of the Standards of the Profession, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F59:N59)","v":4}]
["MASHTI","Q25: Shkenca dhe hulumtimet","Supporting educational centers for Roma, Ashkali and Egyptians","Q4 2023","NPEI",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
["MASHTI","Q25: Shkenca dhe hulumtimet","Scholarships for Roma, Ashkali and Egyptian pupils and students, allocated","Q4 2023","NPEI",0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]
["MASHTI","Q25: Shkenca dhe hulumtimet","National Science Program, designed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"KRIS platform, finalized and launched","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
[null,null,"National contact points for the Horizon Programme, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,null,1,null,1,0,0,5]
[null,null,"Core curriculum for early childhood education, designed and approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Curricular framework for AAP, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Adapted infrastructure (slopes) in 14 schools, inside and outside the facility","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,null,0,null,1,0,0,4]
[null,null,"At least 20 new Inspectors, recruited","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F68:N68)","v":5}]
[null,null,"Reports for 400 teachers and 30 educational institutions on the achieved level of performance, drawn up","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"The role of qAIlity coordinators defined through the approval of the AI","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
[null,null,"All schools have trained qAIlity coordinators who dedicate a certain number of hours to qAIlity issues","Q1 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Approved monitoring standards","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Approval of policies (regulations) for internal qAIlity assurance","Q2 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
[null,null,"The Strategic Plan of KAA, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Twenty-five (25) new education inspectors, recruited through the competitive process","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Fifteen (15) teacher professional development , approved","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Number of licensed teachers","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
[null,null,"Core curricula for grades 11 and 12, developed","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Learning packages for class 10, 11 and 12, developed","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"Training of 1,500 teachers to implement the Core Curriculum","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"The draft law on the Accreditation Agency, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"The draft law on Higher Education, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"The regulation for the internal organization and systematization of workplaces in MAShT, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
[null,null,"The evalAItion carried out and the recommendations included in the new PSAK","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
[null,null,"Implementation of at least 3 priority training programs for each of the fields of higher education, pre-university and AAP","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
[null,null,"MAShT management trained for implementation of the direct budget support instrument","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MASHTI","Q25: Shkenca dhe hulumtimet","MAShT management trained for planning and management of external funds, including delegated management","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
[null,null,"The draft law on early childhood education 0-6 years, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
[null,null,"AI on the duties, responsibilities, procedures and criteria for selecting the director and deputy director of the pre-university educational and training institution with inclusion of gender aspects, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,4]
[null,null,"AI on Procedures for the selection of educational personnel in educational and training institutions (IEAA) of pre-university education with inclusion of gender aspects, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,4]
[null,null,"Information meetings in all DKAs, carried out","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
[null,null,"Trainings with the staff of 6 resource centers, trainings with pre-school, pre-primary level educators as well as primary, lower and upper secondary school teachers","Q3 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
[null,null,"Training of municipal and preschool assessment institutions and teams for the use of instruments for the assessment of children with special needs","Q3 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
[null,null,"Sufficient funding of existing learning centers","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
[null,null,"20 municipalities and schools for the implementation of the platform for prevention and response to abandonment and violence, supported","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
[null,null,"Implementation of instructions and guidelines for the establishment and operation of Learning Centers","Q4 2022","ERA",0,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.58,"d":"58%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},6]
["Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Development"]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The draft law on the organization of the common market of agricultural products, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F100:N100)","v":8}]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The draft law on agricultural land, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The program for agriculture and rural development 2022-2027, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,0,6]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","National plan for organic agriculture, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F103:N103)","v":6}]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","The draft law for veterinary, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F104:N104)","v":8}]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","The plan for the advancement of agro-food enterprises, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,1,1,1,0,6]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","Fish inventory (pilot project) in one (1) river basin, finalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F106:N106)","v":6}]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":1,"d":"100%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},10]
["Ministry of Internal Affairs"]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Draft law for supplementing and amending laws containing special administrative procedures and their harmonization with the law on general administrative procedure, second phase, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F110:N110)","v":8}]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","At least 50 new services on the eKosova platform, operationalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,7]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","The ARIS system and the Central System for Civil Registration, functionalized and interconnected","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F112:N112)","v":5}]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","At least 20% of existing draft laws, by-laws and administrative instructions that contain special administrative procedures and are part of the legislative program, harmonized with LPPA","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","The third phase of digitization of scanned books, namely data verification and data linkage/matching, implemented","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,3]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Provision of civil status services in northern municipalities","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Reviewing the legal framework and populating the central registry with all citizen data, including historical data, reducing cases of undocumented persons","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,0,5]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","The draft law to supplement and amend the Law on the Organization and Functioning of the State Administration and Independent Agencies, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Digital platform for reporting on the implementation of the PAR strategic framework, functionalized","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Six (6) regulations for the implementation of the Law on Public Officials, completed-amended","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,0,5]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Explanatory memorandum for the law on administrative inspection, drafted","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,2]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Draft law on administrative inspection, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","The draft law for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q1 2023)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","The draft law for the second wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Concept document for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Concept document for the fourth wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Agency rationalization plan, revised","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,2]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least thirty-four (34) out of the thirty-eight (38) local action plans for reintegration, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,6]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","The informative circular for the implementation of policies for sustainable reintegration, drafted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,0,0,0,0,3]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Guidelines for monitoring the integration of foreigners, drafted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,2]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Extended Migration Profile 2018-2022, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Easy Migration Profile 2022, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Training of trainers (TT) with the participation of at least ten (10) central and local level officials, for the integration of foreigners, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,2]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least five (5) trainings, for 400 officials at the central and local level, for the implementation of policies for the reintegration and integration of foreigners, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least two (2) officials in the Temporary Reception Center, organized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least 60 women or girls benefiting from reintegration and sustainable integration schemes","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","The draft law for citizenship, completed-amended","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","The draft law to supplement - amend the Law on Foreigners, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least three (3) trainings within the EAIA cooperation roadmap, with the participation of at least three (3) asylum officials, organized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Draft law on housing and residences, completed-amended","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","IT program, with QlikView option, to include Case Management System (CMS) and Border Intelligence (BI) Platform, advanced","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","Interconnection of the NjIP, with at least three (3) operators to receive REU data, funcionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on the Control and Supervision of the State Border, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","The QKMK action plan, fully implemented","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Department for Intelligence and Analysis in KP, established","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,0,6]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least twenty (20) analysts trained in the field of analysis","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least 200 sector police (neighborhood police), assigned","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,2]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The Special Investigations Unit in KP, established in accordance with the Law on Special Prosecution","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least two (2) joint police-prosecutor trainings, for at least ten (10) police officers, for financial investigations, confiscation of assets and effective witness protection, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Liaison officer with EUROPOL, systematized","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Participation in at least four (4) activities within EMPACT","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The draft law for supplementing - amending the Gun Law, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","AI for Joint Investigation Teams, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The Joint Plan between the Kosovo Police and GAIrdia di Finanza, drawn up","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The six-monthly reports on the implementation of the EU-Western Balkans Joint Action Plan against Violent Extremism and Terrorism, drawn up","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MPB","Lufta kunder terrorizmit","TeSAT report for EUROPOL, drafted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MPB","Lufta kunder terrorizmit","Strategy for the prevention of terrorism and violent extremism, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.68,"d":"68%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},7]
["Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade"]
["MINT",null,"Regulation for supplementing - amending Regulation (MINT) no. 01/2018 on Labeling and Marking of Textile Products, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F160:N160)","v":7}]
["MINT",null,"Decision on the publication of the list of titles and references of harmonized standards for electrical equipment intended for use within certain voltage limits, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,1,0,4]
["MINT",null,"Decision on the publication of the list of titles and references of harmonized standards for electromagnetic compatibility, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,1,0,4]
["MINT",null,"Concept document for the field of accreditation, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["MINT",null,"The business information unit, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Accreditation Scheme for certification bodies (EN ISO/IEC 17065), established and functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Laboratory of strength and thermometry, accredited","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MINT",null,"At least ten (10) new officials in the market inspectorate, recruited","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"At least five (5) new officials in AMK, recruited","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"At least ten (10) product safety officers, trained","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"EN ISO/IEC 17020 standard for legal metrology laboratories (mass laboratory, flow volume laboratory, electrical measurement laboratory and pressure laboratory), implemented","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,0,0,2,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"AI for biofuels, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,7]
["MINT",null,"The online system for selling standards, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"The draft law on the register of beneficial owners, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MINT",null,"The draft law on commercial companies, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MINT",null,"At least two (2) new service sectors, digitized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Website for single point of contact, created and launched","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"Strategy for industry development and business support, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MINT",null,"Agency for the support of enterprises, established and operationalized","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MINT",null,"Analysis of the impact of economic zones on the development of SMEs, carried out","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"At least forty (40) businesses that benefits from grants that help businesses to increase production capacity and implement the standards required in the EU market","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"At least 20 businesses (10 until Q2 2022 and 10 until Q2 2023) subsidized in the form of grants for product certification","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"The organizational structure of KIESA approved which addresses the main aspects of performance improvement: the division of responsibilities, financial resources and human capacities","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Complaint mechanism, established","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"Care program, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Investor Care Unit, established","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"Performance evalAItion of support schemes for KIESA businesses, carried out","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"Accreditation Scheme for certification bodies (EN ISO/IEC 17065) established and functionalized","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"At least two (2) officials recruited in the Agency of Metrology","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MINT",null,"At least one (1) new laboratory in the Metrology Agency established","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"Unit for informing businesses about established standards","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MINT",null,"Single point of contact, established and functionalized","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"AI on the defined requirements in relation to commercial communication, including advertising or marketing, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["MINT",null,"Program for industrial ownership, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MINT",null,"At least three (3) trainings for the officials of the Industrial Property Agency, carried out","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"At least one (1) product registered according to the geographical indication","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MINT",null,"Trade policy document, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MINT",null,"One (1) official in the Department of Commerce, recruited","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.61,"d":"61%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},7]
["Ministry of Justice"]
["MD","Avancimi i luftes kunder korrupsioni","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on the Administration of Seized and Confiscated Property, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F201:N201)","v":7}]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","Agreement on legal cooperation with France, signed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,1,1,1,0,5]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","Concept document for the realization of civil rights, including the right of the parties to a trial within a reasonable time, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q2 2022)",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","The draft law on administrative disputes, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,1,0,6]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","Concept Document for the realization of civil rights, including the right of the parties to trial within a reasonable time","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","The draft law on prevention and protection from domestic violence and gender-based violence, approved","Q4 2023","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,7]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":1,"d":"100%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},10]
["Ministry of Finance, Labor and Transfers"]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","The number of trainings held for the Macro Department at MFLT and the Unit for Monitoring of PEs in ME through the IMF-FAD regional technical assistance project funded by the EU","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,0,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F210:N210)","v":4}]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Regular six-monthly reporting of the implementation of the SMFP Action Plan 2022-202","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Regular annAIl reporting of the implementation of the SMFP Action Plan 2022-2024","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F212:N212)","v":5}]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Drafting the analysis of fiscal risks, including the risks coming from PEs, included in the macro-fiscal framework, in strategic documents such as KASh, budget law and PRE","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","QAIrterly financial and performance reports for all PEs, prepared","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Plan for the Implementation of the Youth GAIrantee Scheme, piloted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of women involved in the active measures of the labor market, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,0,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of labor inspectors increased by 100 additional inspectors","Q4 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q4 2022)",1,1,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of inspections by the Labor Inspectorate, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,0,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Grant scheme for crafts","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The draft law on the social assistance scheme, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,6]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The draft law on safety and health at work, drafted and approved","Q2 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The draft law of work, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Sistemi i Teknologjisë së Informacionit të Inspektoratit të Punës, i themelAIr","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The Information Technology System of the Labor Inspectorate, established","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","The draft law for payment services, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Draft document on preventing money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Guidelines for risk factors, developed and approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,1,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Memorandum of understanding for compliance supervision between FIU and CBK, signed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,1,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","At least two (2) supervised mentoring activities, developed","Q4 2023","NPEI",0,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,2]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Increased number of suspicious transaction/activity reports received","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Methodologies for risk assessment, revised/drafted","Q3 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Project - code for completion - amendment of the Customs and Excises Code in Kosovo, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Combating the informal economy and customs fraud through increased cooperation and coordination between Customs, law enforcement agencies and other relevant institutions, measured by the number of inspections carried out, the number of operations undertaken, the results achieved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Moving to public property and fully operationalizing at least one (1) customs terminal","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Draft document for the review of tax policies, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","The number of activities within projects to improve tax compliance, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,0,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Increased number of risk-based inspections and compliance visits","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,0,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,2]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Number of actions taken to improve tax compliance","Q2 2023","ERA",1,0,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on Public Procurement, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q1 2022)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","The draft law on the amendment of the Law on the Auditor General and the National Audit Office of Kosovo, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Internal audit committees in all budget organizations, including the municipal level, established","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Concept Document for the establishment of an independent fiscal body approved after consultation with stakeholders including the EU","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Fifty (50) information sessions for municipalities, line ministries, regulatory and justice institutions","Q2 2023","ERA",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Number of schemes harmonized with State Aid Rules","Q1 2023","ERA",1,0,1,1,0,0,1,0,0,4]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","The draft law for state aid, revised","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,1,0,7]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Regulation on Horizontal Aid, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,1,1,1,0,5]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Number of additional schemes notified in SAD (state aid department)","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.66,"d":"66%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},7]
["Ministry of Communities and Returns"]
["MKK",null,"The strategy for the protection and promotion of the rights of communities and their members, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F251:N251)","v":7}]
["MKK",null,"Up to 56 displaced and socially vulnerable people in the Municipality of Graçanica, organized in permanent housing units","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,0,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F252:N252)","v":4}]
["MKK",null,"Five (5) meetings at the municipal level, according to regions, for the implementation of the Strategy for the Protection and Promotion of the Rights of Communities and their Members, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F253:N253)","v":3}]
["MKK",null,"Inter-Ministerial Coordinating Group for Durable Solutions for Displaced Persons, established","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F254:N254)","v":3}]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.25,"d":"25%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},3]
["Ministry of Health"]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on measures to prevent the abuse of narcotic and psychotropic substances for children, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F258:N258)","v":8}]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on measures for medical, psychological assistance, rehabilitation and reintegration of child victims of abuse, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on the combined remarks on the tobacco packaging unit, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,7]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","List and price list of health services, drawn up","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,4]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","The draft law for the prevention and control of Infectious diseases, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F262:N262)","v":6}]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The Health Sector Strategy 2022-2032, drafted","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F263:N263)","v":6}]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The draft law for health insurance, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,8]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The draft law for health, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,7]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for the implementation of exemption from the payment of premiums, co-payments and co-financing for health services, drafted","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,0,0,1,1,1,1,0,5]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for out-of-hospital drug scheme, drafted","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,1,0,7]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for medical treatment outside public health institutions, completed-amended","Q1 2022","ERA",1,1,0,1,0,1,1,1,0,6]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","Feasibility study for SIsh, completed","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.83,"d":"83%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},9]
["Office of the Prime Minister"]
["ZKM","Krijimi i administrates efektive publike","The annAIl report on the evalAItion of the performance of executive agencies, drafted","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F273:N273)","v":4}]
["ZKM","Krijimi i administrates efektive publike","The final report on the performance of the executive agencies, approved by the Government","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,1,1,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F274:N274)","v":4}]
["ZKM","Promovimi i lirive fetare","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on Religious Freedom in Kosovo, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q3 2022)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ZKM","Promovimi i lirive fetare","By-laws within the framework of the law on religious freedoms, drafted and approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","Number of implemented recommendations of the Ombudsman","Q4 2023","NPEI",0,0,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,3]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","The number of responses received from the responsible institutions regarding the recommendations addressed to the Ombudsman","Q4 2023","NPEI",0,0,0,0,1,0,1,0,0,2]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","Raising to at least 60% the implementation of the recommendations of the People's Advocate and 95% providing answers to the addressed recommendations within the legal deadline","Q4 2021","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,0,1,0,0,6]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te njeriut","Human rights indicator framework developed","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,0,5]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","The National Plan for Gender EqAIlity 2023-2026, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Sixteen (16) AI derived from the child protection law, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,1,0,6]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Raising public awareness for the prevention of violence against women, fighting gender stereotypes, and the rights gAIranteed by the legal framework for gender eqAIlity by preparing five (5) video spots and three (3) discussion tables","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","AI (affirmative measure) for the registration of joint real estate in the name of two spouses, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,1,0,6]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","By-law for the implementation of gender budgeting, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,0,1,1,0,6]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Affirmative measures to increase the number of women in decision-making positions - executive level, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,1,0,0,6]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Support of 10 NGOs that aim to strengthen the role of women in society","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","At least ten (10) trainings on advancing the realization of inheritance rights; decision making; peace, security and justice, maintained","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,1,0,0,3]
["ZKM","Krijimi i nje mjedisi te lire per media","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on the Independent Media Commission, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q2 2021)",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,7]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.59,"d":"59%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},6]
["Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports"]
["MKRS","Mbrojtja efektive e pronësisë intelektAIle","AI për procedurat, kushtet për licencimin e organizatave të menaxhimit kolektiv, i miratAIr","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,0,1,1,0,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F293:N293)","v":6}]
["MKRS","Mbrojtja efektive e pronësisë intelektAIle","Së paku një (1) Shoqatë për Menaxhim Kolektiv në fushën e letërsisë, e licencAIr","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F294:N294)","v":2}]
["MKRS","Përmirësimi i zbatimit të të drejtave dhe lirive themelore","Projektligji për trashëgiminë kulturore, i miratAIr","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F295:N295)","v":8}]
["MKRS","Përmirësimi i zbatimit të të drejtave dhe lirive themelore","Akte nënligjore në kAIdër të avancimit të mbrojtjes së trashëgimisë kulturore, të hartAIra dhe të miratAIra","Q4 2022","ERA",1,1,1,0,0,1,1,1,0,{"$f":"SUM(F296:N296)","v":6}]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.75,"d":"75%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},8]
["Ministry of Local Government Administration"]
["MAPL","N/A","Draft document for the Law on the Commissioning and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,{"$f":"SUM(F300:N300)","v":4}]
["MAPL","N/A","The draft law on the amendment of the Law on the Provision for Utilization and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["MAPL","N/A","The draft law to complete the amendment of the Law on Inter-municipal Cooperation, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["MAPL","N/A","AI for open local administration, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["MAPL","N/A","Ex-post evalAItion of legislation on local democracy mechanisms, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["MAPL","N/A","The membership of the Republic of Kosovo and municipalities in the Partnership for Open Government, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["MAPL","N/A","The state platform eKomunat (eMunicipalities), functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,1,1,1,1,0,0,0,6]
["MAPL","N/A","Placement of eKiosks in 20 municipalities that do not have financial capacity","Q4 2023","NPEI",1,1,0,0,1,1,0,0,0,4]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":13},{"v":0.13,"d":"13%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":13},2]
[]
[]
["Each measure is assesed along all criterias with either value \"1\" or value \"0\". Value \"1\" represents positive assessment, whilst \"0\" negative one. In cases where a measure is assesed negatively under the first criteria, then the entire measure is automaticaly assessed negatively.\n\nAfter the assessment of all individAIl measures is completed, ministries recieve one of the final gradings:\n\n- If the sum of all elements is in the range 0-4 = Some complexity\n- If the sum of all elements is in the range 5-9 = High complexity\n\nFinaly, we count all high complexity measures and transfer the final score to the the overall sheet under column “Measure complexity\":\n1. Higher than 0% = 1\n2. Higher than 10% = 2\n3. Higher than 20% = 3\n4. Higher than 30% = 4\n5. Higher than 40% = 5\n6. Higher than 50% = 6\n7. Higher than 60% = 7\n8. Higher than 70% = 8\n9. Higher than 80% = 9\n10. Higher than 90% = 10"]

{"sheet":"Criteria 2","index":2,"n_rows":351,"n_cols":5,"rows_kept":351,"merged":[[0,0,0,4],[2,0,2,4],[14,0,14,2],[15,0,15,2],[16,0,16,4],[94,0,94,2],[95,0,95,2],[96,0,96,4],[124,0,124,2],[125,0,125,2],[126,0,126,4],[144,0,144,2],[145,0,145,2],[146,0,146,4],[172,0,172,2],[173,0,173,2],[174,0,174,4],[235,0,235,2],[236,0,236,2],[237,0,237,4],[250,0,250,2],[251,0,251,2],[252,0,252,4],[295,0,295,2],[296,0,296,2],[297,0,297,4],[301,0,301,2],[302,0,302,2],[303,0,303,4],[314,0,314,2],[315,0,315,2],[316,0,316,4],[327,0,327,2],[328,0,328,2],[329,0,329,4],[336,0,336,2],[337,0,337,2],[338,0,338,4],[347,0,347,2],[348,0,348,2],[350,0,350,4]]}
["Criteria 2: Planing vs EU obligations\nKosovo's specific EU obligations are outlined in the EU Country Report and conclusions of the seven SAA sub-committee meetings. Kosovo institutions ensure the implementation of these obligations by preparing the National Program for European Integration and European Reform Agenda Action Plan. Challenge however is that often there is a gap between these two realities. Planning by line ministries often does not cover all EU specified obligations. Therefore, the purpose of this assessment is to differentiate between more and less prudent planning of EU obligations by the line ministries. "]
["Institution","EU obligations","Measures addressing EU Obligations","Assessment","All measures (measures not adressing EU Obligations)"]
["Ministry of Economy"]
["ME","Adopt the Energy Strategy 2022-2031, in line with the European Green Deal and the Green Agenda for the Western Balkans, and ensure its consistency with the draft National Energy and Climate Plan (Q2/2022)","Energy Strategy Implementation Program, approved",1,"Projektligji për energji, i miratAIr"]
["ME","Progress on finalizing the Integrated National Energy and Climate Plan (Q4/2022)","Energy and Climate Plan 2021-2030, approved",1,"Projektligji për rregullatorin e energjisë, i miratAIr"]
["ME","Adopt the Law on Renewable Energy Sources introducing a competitive bidding process for renewable energy projects in compliance with the state aid legislation (Q4/2022)","The draft law on renewable energy sources, approved\nDesigning the competitive scheme for BRE",1,"Rregullorja për skemën e re mbështetëse për BRE"]
["ME","Finalise the Kosovo 2030 Digital Agenda [Q2 2022].","Digital Agenda for Kosovo 2030, approved",1,"Projektligji i plotësAIr-ndryshAIr për ndërmarrje publike, bazAIr në rekomandimet e BE dhe praktikat e mira, i miratAIr"]
["ME","In line with sustainable green transition in Europe, undertake the second phase of the comprehensive study on alternative sustainable energy sources (Q2/2022)",null,0,"Aktet nënligjore të miratAIra"]
["ME","Prepare the decommissioning of the non-working parts of Kosovo A, take the decision on the land to be assigned for the hazardous waste storage, and prepare an environmental and social impact assessment with proper public consultation with a view to taking a final decision about the land (Q2/2022)",null,0,"Njëzet (20) pirgje të rrjetit mobil, ‘5G ready’, të lidhura me infrastrukturë fikse brezgjerë"]
["ME","Complete the additional works supporting the EU-funded project on the Kosovo B Thermal Power Plant (Q3/2022 Unit B2, Q3/2023 Unit B1)",null,0,"Hapja e tregut të energjisë për konsumatorët e nivelit të tensionit 35 kv dhe 10 kv"]
["ME","Take measures to plan replenishment of the Energy Efficiency Fund on an annAIl basis and extend it to residential buildings and small and medium enterprises (SMEs) (Q4/2022)",null,0,"Kodi i etikës dhe qeverisjes korporative të ndërmarrjeve publike, i miratAIr"]
["ME","Adopt energy efficiency incentives for the private sector and households by focusing on social aspects and low-income households (state incentives) and utilisation of existing EU programmes in Kosovo (Q4/2022).",null,0]
["ME","Conclude the alignment of Kosovo’s legislation with the European Electronic Communications Code, the EU Network and Information Security Directive and the EU’s Toolbox for 5G cybersecurity",null,0]
["ME","Prepare the programme for protection of vulnerable consumers and prepare a plan and mitigation measures to support these consumers",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.36,"d":"36%"}]
["Total score",null,null,4]
["Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Infrastructure"]
["MMPHI","To invest in road maintenance and inspections, organize prevention campaigns and create a systematic monitoring mechanism for collecting accident data;","Road Law, Approved",1,"AI për kontrollimin e rregullsisë teknike të automjeteve në rrugë, i miratAIr"]
["MMPHI","To transpose the EU acquis in the railway market and the adoption of the new law on railway safety and interoperability;","Law on Railway Safety, Approved",1,"Koncept dokumenti për hekurudha, i miratAIr"]
["MMPHI","To approve the strategy for multimodal transport, which should include, among others, the strategy of civil aviation; continue efforts to harmonize Kosovo's aviation regulation with the Agreement on the European Common Aviation Area;","The 2023-2025 action plan for the implementation of the 2023-2030 multimodal transport strategy, approved",1,"Koncept dokumenti për transportin e mallrave të rrezikshme, i miratAIr"]
["MMPHI","To adopt the Intelligent Transport System (ITS) strategy and action plan, ensure sufficient capacity and resources for implementation and continue efforts to harmonize passenger rights in all modes of transport with the EU acquis.","Intelligent Transport System Strategy (ITS), approved",1,"Pritet të miratohet ne Q4 2023"]
["MMPHI","In the field of road safety, Kosovo should continue harmonizing legislation with the EU acquis in the field of education, awareness campaigns, implementation of activities to achieve better results in accordance with the goals of the United Nations and the European Union to halve the number of road deaths and injuries by 2030.","The action plan for road safety approved in October 2020 is included in the national program for road safety and the 2023-2030 action plan.",1,"Strategjia e transportit multimodal 2023-2030, e miratAIr me 14.03.2023"]
["MMPHI","Update the Multimodal Transport Strategy to include sustainable and smart elements, in line with the EU and WB Sustainable and Smart Mobility Strategy, the European Green Deal and the Green Agenda for the Western Balkans (Q4/2022)","The 2023-2025 action plan for the implementation of the 2023-2030 multimodal transport strategy, approved",1,"Projektligji për Vlerësimin e Ndikimit në Mjedis është miratAIr në Kuvend me 15 dhjetor 2022."]
["MMPHI","Approve the 'Administrative instruction on the Framework for the deployment of intelligent transport systems (ITS)' (Q2/2022).","Administrative instruction for ITS, Approved",1,"Udherrefyesi per Ekonomine Qarkore I miratAIr ne mars 2023"]
["MMPHI","Make efforts to begin to transpose the EU road transport acquis. (continuous)","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on Road Transport, approved",1,"Me datë 17.05.2022, me Nr.prot.2706/22 është miratAIr plotësimi dhe ndryshimi i AI nr. 30/2014 per kushtet, menyrat, parametrat dhe vlerat kufizuese te shkarkimit te ujerave te ndotura ne rrjetin e kanalizimit publik dhe ne trupin ujor dhe është publikAIr ne websiten e Gazetes Zyrtare të Republikës së Kosovës me 17.05.2022."]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Sectoral Strategy of Multimodal transport which includes the civil aviation\nstrategy (Q4/2022)","Multimodal transport strategy 2023-2030",1,"Ështe formAIr Grupi ndërministror për hartimin e  projekt marrëveshjes I cili ka harmonizAIr draftin  final  dhe  pritet të nënshkruhet ne Q1 të vitit të ardhshem."]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should increase its political commitment to address environmental degradation and the challenges of climate change and significantly improve the implementation of its legislation, to harmonize it with the Green Agenda for the goals of the Western Balkans;","The Draft Law on Climate Change was approved by the Government on 12.07.2023 with decision No. 02/151.",1,"Konceptdokumenti është hartAIr dhe gjendet  në diskutim  publik me  palet e  interesit, sipas  përfundimit të  procesit te konsultimeve do te procedohet per  miratim ne Qeveri."]
["MMPHI","Effectively address the issue of illegal landfills and introduce circular economy measures to reduce waste, develop and approve inter-municipal integrated waste management plans and create an extended producer responsibility system;","The number of illegal landfills in the municipalities of Kosovo, identified and reduced",1,"Plani i veprimit për siguri rrugore miratAIr në tetor 2020 është përfshirë në programin nacional për siguri rrugore dhe planin e veprimit 2023-2030."]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should also amend and implement environmental and strategic impact assessment laws","The Draft Law on Strategic Environmental Assessment, approved",1,"\n Ka përfundAIr Draft Programi Nacional dhe Plani i Veprimit për siguri në trafikun rrugor 2023-2030, ku pritet të miratohet  deri në fund të këtij viti.\n"]
["MMPHI","Kosovo must increase capacities at all levels and set realistic targets and timelines to ensure effective implementation of its integrated waste management and circular economy;","Administrative Instruction for Packaging and packaging waste, approved",1,"Ekipi punues ka vazhdAIr punën në identifikimin e akseve rrugore me rrezikshmëri të lartë dhe poashtu ka vazhdAIr puna në përmirësimin e cilësisë së rrjetit rrugor.\nNe rruget nacionale dhe rajonale jane vendosur pahite elastike dhe sinjalizimi vertikal dhe horizontal\n"]
["MMPHI","The river basin authority must become operational as a matter of urgency","The Regional Authority of River Basins is operational with Regulation (qrk)-no. 05/2017 on the internal organization and systematization of workplaces of the Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning approved on June 13, 2017",1,"Këto direktiva janë përfshirë në koncept dokumentin për hekurudhat dhe pas miratimit të tij nga Qeveria do të transpozohen në projektligjin për plotësimin dhe ndryshimin e ligjit për hekurudhat gjatë vitit 2024."]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Law on climate change (Q4/2022)","The draft law on climate change, approved",1,"Ështe formAIr Grupi ndërministror për hartimin e  projekt marrëveshjes I cili ka harmonizAIr draftin  final  dhe  pritet të nënshkruhet ne Q1 të vitit të ardhshem."]
["MMPHI","Significantly and urgently strengthen administrative capacities (ongoing) and report on\nprogress (qAIrterly)","Number of inspectors trained to control the implementation of environmental legislation",1,"E drejta e Avio udhëtarëve është e rregullAIr përmes  Rregullores e BE-së nr. 261/2004 e cila është transponAIr në Kosovë përmes  Rregullores MI-2008/5 mbi të Drejtat e Avio Udhëtarëve. \nImplementimi  i Rregullores MI-2008/5 është plotësisht i kompletAIr.\nProjektligji per  transporitn ka perfshire  pjesene  te drejtave  te udhetareve ne  transportin e udhetareve me autobus sipas  rekomandimeve te dalura nga TCT-ja , ndersa  pjesa e  hekurdhave  eshte e transpozAI rn e  ligjin  ekzistues  te hekurudhave  , megjithate ne  kAIder te  Konceptdokumentit per hekurudha eshte perfshire  edhe  rregullorja e re per te drejat e  udhetareve ne transporitn  hekurudhore me  kete rats gjate hartimit  te proijkeligjit te ri per hekurudha  do te perfshihet  edhe kjo qeshtje.\n"]
["MMPHI","Prepare an inventory of Greenhouse Gas emissions covering up to 2020 (Q2/2022).","Greenhouse gas inventory for 2021, prepared",1,"Është miratAIr ne Qeveri Koncept dokumenti per fushen e mjedisit me daten 27.10.2023 "]
["MMPHI","Adopt the amended Strategical Environmental Assessment Law (Q4/2022).","The draft law to supplement and amend the Law on Strategic Environmental Assessment, approved",1,"Është miratAIr ne Qeveri Koncept dokumenti per fushen e mjedisit me daten 27.10.2023 "]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Draft Law on Air Protection from Pollution (Q2/2022).","The law on the protection of air from pollution was approved by the Assembly on 23.06.2022 and was published in the Official Gazette on 07.07.2023",1,"Rishikimi i Strategjisë Shtetërore për Ujëra 2023-2027 dhe Plani i Veprimit 2023-2025 është miratAIr në Qeveri me vendim Nr.18/ 145  të datës 07.06.2023."]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Draft Law on the Establishment of a National Spatial Information\nInfrastructure (INSPIRE) (Q2/2022).","Ligji për krijimin e infrastrukturës kombëtare të informacionit hapësinor në Republikën e Kosovës eshte miratAIr ne Kuvend me 14.06.2022 dhe eshte publikAIr ne Gazeten Zyrtare me 28.06.2023",1,"Është miratAIr ne Qeveri Koncept dokumenti per fushen e mjedisit me daten 27.10.2023 "]
["MMPHI","Finalize the establishment of the groundwater monitoring network for the entire\nterritory and start collecting data. (Q4/2022).","The underground water monitoring network has been created, which currently contains 40 monitoring stations throughout the territory of Kosovo. At the monitoring stations, in all ponds, sensors for hydrometric measurements have been installed, which simultaneously measure and store data permanently throughout the year. Monitoring of the physico-chemical qAIlity of underground water has so far only been done in 3 river basins: Ibër, Lepenc and Morava e Binces, and this type of monitoring was done for the first time in Kosovo in May 2023 (T2/ 2023) . The same monitoring was repeated in October 2023. The monitoring will continue in the future.",1,"Me vendim te Sekretarit te Pergjithshëm te MMPHI  eshte themelAIr Sekretariati Teknik I Keshillit Kombetar per Ndryshime Klimatike me anetare nga disa institucione te perfshira."]
["MMPHI","Adopt the draft Law on Kosovo Waters and secondary legislation on Conditions,\nWays, Parameters and Limiting Values of Wastewater Discharge in the Public\nSewerage Network and in the Water Body (Q3/2022)","Concept document for the field of water, approved",1]
["MMPHI","Draft the Concept Document on Nature Protection (Q4/2022)","Concept document for the field of nature protection, approved",1]
["MMPHI","Amend the Law on Environmental Impact Assessment according to EU standard’s with\nthe inclusion of social component (Q2/2022)","The Draft Law on Environmental Impact Assessment was approved by the Assembly on December 15, 2022",1]
["MMPHI","Approval of the Spatial Plan for the National Park \"Sharri\", (Q2/2023) and approval of\nthe Spatial Plan “Bjeshkët e Nemuna” (Q4 2022)","On 07.06.2023, the Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo approved the Spatial Plan document of the \"Bjeshket e Nemuna\" National Park",1]
["MMPHI","Adopt the draft Law on Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (Q2/2022)","Law on the prevention and integrated control of pollution, approved in the Assembly of Kosovo on 08.03.2023 (it was not planned in PKIE 2023)",1]
["MMPHI","To increase the coverage of waste collection, implement extensive reduction, separation of recycling and reuse of waste","Beginning of establishment of deposit return system for bottles, plastic and cans",1]
["MMPHI","To implement the climate change strategy and the climate change action plan","Climate Change Strategy Action Plan",1]
["MMPHI","Air qAIlity plans for areas in which pollutant levels clearly exceed limit values must be approved","Revised National Air QAIlity Plan, approved",1]
["MMPHI","Effective monitoring and management of water protection zones still needs to be improved. An effective water monitoring system, with publicly available data, must be set up urgently.;","Creation of the online Environmental Information System",1]
["MMPHI","Start drafting a long-term decarbonisation strategy (Q1/2022)","Beginning of decarbonization strategy design",1]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Strategy for Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development 2022-\n030 (Q4/2022).","Strategy for Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development 2022-2030, approved",1]
["MMPHI","Adopt the Action Plan for Air QAIlity (Q4/2022) and an air qAIlity plan for Pristina\n(Q3/2022).","Revised National Air QAIlity Plan approved",1]
["MMPHI","Develop and start to implement comprehensive institutional capacity development plan\nfor implementation and enforcement of the waste management legislation.","Municipal level training for the implementation of waste management legislation",1]
["MMPHI","Start the preparation of waste prevention programs (Q2/2022)","Start of implementation of hazardous waste management projects: facility for temporary storage of hazardous waste, decommissioning of Kosovo A",1]
["MMPHI","Adopt the “Drini i Bardhë” management plan (Q3/2022) and identify and monitor other\nrisk areas regarding ground water and surface water and report on the state of play and\nproposed remedial measures (Q4/2022).","The management plan for the Drini i Bardhë river basin, finalized",1]
[null,"Start drafting the Law on Nature Protection (Q1/2023)","Supplement-amendment of Law no. 03/L-233 on the protection of nature",1]
[null,"Approval Drafting of the detailed regulatory plans for the Sharri National Park and for\nthe National Park “Bjeshket e Nemuna” (Q2/2022)","Spatial plan of the national park \"Bjeshket e Nemuna\", approved",1]
["MMPHI","Finalize the drafting of the river basin management plans for the remaining water bodies\n(i.e. Ibër, Morava e Binçës and Lepenc) (Q2/2024).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should start targeting and expanding the use of alternative fuels, in line with the Green Agenda for the Western Balkans and the Smart and Sustainable Mobility Strategy for the Western Balkans.",null,0]
["MMPHI","Work should begin on establishing the Road Safety Agency and develop a comprehensive Road Safety Strategy for 2022-2030, including setting targets and collecting more reliable accident data.",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should implement the recommendations of the CONNECTA report to improve the qAIlity of the road network and actions, as defined in the regional action plan of the Transport Community Treaty for road safety.",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo must ensure the signing and implementation of the 2020-2024 financial agreement with INFRAKOS, - The Railway Infrastructure Manager.",null,0]
["MMPHI","The aviation sector continues to face a number of challenges arising from Kosovo's non-membership in several international civil aviation organizations.",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should continue harmonizing with the remaining points of the first phase of the HPEA.",null,0]
["MMPHI","Transpose into national legislation the Council Directive 92/106/EEC on the establishment of common rules for certain types of combined transport of goods between Member States. (Q3/2022).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Fully implement the actions set out in the Road Safety regional action plan adopted in\nOctober 2020 (continuous)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Develop a comprehensive national road safety strategy for 2021-2030, including the\nsetting of targets (Q4/2022) and collection of more reliable crash data. (Q4/2022)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Reflect on the road-safety institutional set-up for addressing the challenges as soon as\npossible and carry out an assessment defining the needs to improve the road safety\nmanagement (reflecting the discussions in the SC meeting on establishing a lead\nAgency for road safety) (Q4-2022)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Continue to identify high-risk road axes and implement in full the recommendations to\nimprove the qAIlity of the road network. (continuous)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Continue the transposition of the EU rail market acquis and, in particular, align the Law\non Railways with Directive 2012/34, as amended by Directive 2016/2370 (continuous)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Ensure the signature of the 2020-2024 financial agreement, submitted by INFRAKOS\nin October 2019, between the Infrastructure Manager and the competent authorities\n(Q1/2023).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Complete the transposition of the remaining items under phase 1 of the European\nCommon Aviation Area (ECAA) Agreement(Q4/2022)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Continue efforts to transpose the EU passenger rights acquis across all modes of\ntransport (continuous)",null,0]
["MMPHI","Harmonizing and starting to implement legal provisions on environmental liability, damage and crime",null,0]
["MMPHI","Apply the polluter pays principle and raise public awareness of environmental protection",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo still needs to harmonize its environmental protection with the environmental liability directive",null,0]
["MMPHI","Although the environmental inspection legislation has been reformulated, it has not yet been adopted and the enforcement capacity is still lacking",null,0]
["MMPHI","Inter-institutional coordination and involvement of civil society should be increased",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should take on the responsibilities of raising awareness from the international community and civil society organizations",null,0]
["MMPHI","Kosovo should effectively implement measures to ban coal for heating and start introducing subsidies and investments for other forms of heating",null,0]
["MMPHI","The legal framework should include extended producer responsibility and the polluter pays principle",null,1]
["MMPHI","Hazard and flood risk maps must be completed. Sewage and untreated discharges remain the main sources of water pollution, especially to rivers",null,0]
["MMPHI","Effective measures to ensure the protection of endangered species",null,0]
["MMPHI","Implementation of the legal framework for the export and import of hazardous chemicals",null,0]
["MMPHI","Establishing a chemical poison control center",null,0]
["MMPHI","Installation of Trans-European Services for Telematics between Administrations (TESTA) as a prerequisite for the installation of the European Commission's Common Emergency Communication and Information System (CECIS)",null,0]
["MMPHI","The strategic and legislative framework should be adapted to the EU's strategic goals derived from the Green Agenda for the Western Balkans",null,0]
["MMPHI","The full implementation of the climate change strategy should serve as a guide to achieving the objectives of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change agreement",null,0]
["MMPHI","Implement the climate change strategy and the action plan on climate change",null,0]
["MMPHI","Prepare a timetable for legislative approximation and the financial implications of\nactions related to climate change (Q3/2022).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Improve inter-institutional cooperation to ensure the integration of climate change into\nother sectors, particularly in energy and transport, and to strengthen the role of the\nNational Council on Climate Change (ongoing).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Significantly and urgently strengthen awareness-raising activities (ongoing) and report\non progress (qAIrterly).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Adopt the draft Law on Waste (Q2/2022).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Prepare and adopt the transposition into KO law of the EU waste stream directives\n(Q1/2023).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Draft the Administrative Instruction for the full transposition of the Nitrates Directive\n(Q1/2023).",null,0]
["MMPHI","Adopt the amended Law on noise protection (Q2/2022)",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.49,"d":"49%"}]
["Total score",null,null,5]
["Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and Innovation"]
["MASHTI","Kosovo should develop a strategic approach for the development, prioritization and promotion of scientific research and innovation and ensure higher government spending on scientific research; seek to stimulate investments from the private sector by completing a Smart Specialization Strategy","National Science Program, designed",1,"AI për plotësim-ndryshimin e AI për Standardet dhe Procedurat e Verifikimit të Standardeve të Profesionit, i miratAIr"]
["MASHTI","The effort to increase participation in the Horizon Europe program should also be continued;","National contact points for the Horizon Programme, operationalized",1,"Mbështetja e qendrave mësimore për romë, ashkalinj dhe egjiptianë"]
["MASHTI","The implementation of the new curricular framework for basic education should be finalized with qAIlity texts and by providing sustainable training for teachers;","Core Curriculum for Early Childhood Education, Developed and Approved Curriculum Framework for AAP,  approved",1,"Bursat për nxënës dhe studentë romë, ashkalinj dhe egjiptianë, të ndara"]
["MASHTI","Prepare and approve the new Education Strategic Plan 2022-2026 [Q2 202].","Done",1,"Platforma KRIS, e finalizAIr dhe lansAIr"]
["MASHTI","Ensure successful implementation of the Law on Education Inspection, and provide the\nCommission with intended targets for school inspections for the upcoming years.(Q4 2022)","20 new Inspectors, recruited",1,"Infrastruktura e pershtatur (pjerrinat) në 14 shkolla, brenda dhe jashte objektit"]
["MASHTI","Adopt the Law on Education in Early Childhood [Q2 2022]","The draft law on early childhood education 0-6 years, approved",1]
["MASHTI","Law on  Textbooks and Teaching Materials [Q32022]","The draft law on the Accreditation Agency, approved",1]
["MASHTI","Law on Higher Education [Q4 2022].","The draft law on Higher Education, approved",1]
["MASHTI"," Adopt the Law on the Kosovo Accreditation Agency [Q2 2022]","The draft law on the Accreditation Agency, approved",1]
["MASHTI","Continue efforts to increase the early childhood enrolment rate of children 0-5 years, by\nincreasing the number of childcare facilities through building new facilities as well as adapting\nschool / alternative spaces available for the provision of services in early childhood education.",null,0]
["MASHTI","Kosovo should also provide statistical data on the number of researchers, the percentage of GDP spent on research and innovation, and performance in relation to the priorities of the European Research Area.",null,0]
["MASHTI","The qAIlity of education must be improved and key legislation (including pre-school education, higher education and the accreditation agency) must be approved by the Assembly.",null,0]
["MASHTI","Kosovo should increase the provision of qAIlity professional education and training for the professions required in accordance with the Youth GAIrantee",null,0]
["MASHTI","Kosovo must continue efforts to provide children with disabilities access to qAIlity education.",null,0]
["MASHTI","Continue ppublishing accurate data in the fields of education and youth (including GDP\nspending on education), which should be measurable, traceable and comparable over time.\nEnsure that the Education Management Information System is further developed to meet the\ncurrent and future needs in this area.[Q4 2022]",null,0]
["MASHTI","Enhance the administration of, increase participation in and implementation of international\nassessments.[Q4 2022]",null,0]
["MASHTI","Continue efforts to ensure access to online education for all children in basic education,\nparticularly those from families with low income and marginalized groups.",null,0]
["MASHTI","Continue efforts to increase the enrolment rate of pupils/students with special needs and prevent\ndropout.[Q4 2022]",null,0]
["MASHTI","Improve qAIlity of education at all levels by systematically applying the existing qAIlity\nassurance mechanisms, such as qAIlity coordinators, school inspections in basic education, and\nensure strict monitoring of the Kosovo Accreditation Agency conditions for accreditation of\nhigher education programmes.[Q4 2022]",null,0]
["MASHTI","Finalise a general review of the legislation related to teacher professional development and\nteacher licensing [Q4 2022] with a view to take concrete steps to provide for resources for\nprofessional development of teachers and link teacher salaries with their trainings and\nperformance [Q1 2023].",null,0]
["MASHTI","Continue to address the risk of corruption and political influence, in close consultation with\nstudents, and report on actions taken including as regards merit-based selection of teaching and\nmanagement staff [Q4 2022].",null,0]
["MASHTI","\nIncrease participation in the new Erasmus+ programme.[Q4 2022]",null,0]
["MASHTI","Continue to provide statistical data (according to the Frascati ManAIl of the OECD) on the\namount, and percentage of GDP, spent on Research and Innovation, and on performance\nrelated to the European Research Area Priorities.",null,0]
["MASHTI","Provide the necessary statistical indicators for Kosovo to participate in the European\nInnovation Scoreboard (Q4, 2022).",null,0]
["MASHTI","Strengthen Horizon Europe participation to reach at least 2019 levels and participate in key\nHorizon Europe initiatives (ESS, EOSC, EuroHPC), in particular the EuroHPC Joint\nUndertaking (Q2, 2022) and join the 11th round of the European Social Survey (Q2, 2022).",null,0]
["MASHTI","Complete the Entrepreneurial Discovery Process of the Smart Specialisation Strategy\nprocess [Q4 2022].",null,0]
["MASHTI","Participate in regional innovation measures.",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.33,"d":"33%"}]
["Total score",null,null,4]
["Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Development"]
["MBPZHR","Adopt of the Agriculture and Rural Development Program","The program for agriculture and rural development 2022-2027, approved",1,"Plani kombëtar për bujqësi organike, i miratAIr"]
["MBPZHR","Draft the Law on Agricultural Land","The draft law on agricultural land, approved",1,"Projektligj i për veterinarinë, i miratAIr"]
["MBPZHR","Adoption of Law on common market organisation","The draft law on the organization of the common market of agricultural products, approved",1,"Plani për avancimin e ndërmarrjeve agro-ushqimore, i miratAIr"]
["MBPZHR","Complete the process to establish an inventory of fish species in one pilot zone","Fish inventory (pilot project) in one (1) river basin, finalized",1]
["MBPZHR","Ensure adeqAIte financial resources for the Kosovo Food and Veterinary Agency (KFVA) (Q3 2022) in order inter-alia, to have an adeqAIte number of inspectors",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Approve Administrative Instructions on animal by-products transposing Regulation (EC) 1069/2009 (Q3 2022) and implementing Regulation (EC) 142/2011 (Q4 2022);",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Implement the aspects of the Strategy of the Rural Development 2022-28 concerning the upgrading of Agri- food establishments;",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Continue strengthening cooperation mechanisms with Serbian counterparts to fight against illegal trade of live animals and agri-food products (qAIrterly reports to be sent to the Commission).",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Finalize and adopt the AI for the verification of agricultural products and foodstuffs (Q3 2022) and proceed with the registration of Sharri cheese and Rahoveci wine as geographical indicators (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Finalize and adopt the new Law on Wines",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Adopt the Law on Spirit Drinks",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Approve the concept document on Land Regulation",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Start the FADN project for 2021-24",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Effectively use the deliverables achieved with EU assistance, since they have been produced with the aim to secure effective and sustainable development of Kosovo’s agri-rural sector",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Increase efforts to strengthen administrative capacity to ensure proper legislative alignment;",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Further align its control of fisheries as well as aqAIculture, market policy and data collection with the acquis;",null,0]
["MBPZHR","Prepare TAIEX applications for the methodology of data collection and advancement of the fisheries legislation and policies",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.24,"d":"24%"}]
["Total score",null,null,3]
["Ministry of Internal Affairs"]
["MPB","Continue implementing the priority actions of the implementing arrangement of the Joint Action Plan between EU and Western Balkans.","The six-monthly reports on the implementation of the EU-Western Balkans Joint Action Plan against Violent Extremism and Terrorism, drawn up",1,"Të paktën 20% të projektligjeve ekzistuese, draft ligjeve, akteve nënligjore dhe udhëzimeve administrative që përmbajnë procedura të veçanta administrative dhe janë pjesë e programit legjislativ, të harmonizAIra me LPPA"]
["MPB","Improve the migration and asylum data management systems, including through the introduction of a harmonized and consistent biometric registration and data collection mechanism, which is compliant with applicable international and EU standards as well as ensure inter-communicability/inter-operability of information management systems and databases including at the regional level, through further developing the Migration Management Information System. Provide capacity-building trainings for government officials (local and national) on data management. GradAIlly increase the expert/specialized staffing of relevant institutions in the migration and asylum area in transparent hiring procedures with a focus on competence and the required technical expertise.","The IT program, with the option of QlikView, to include the Case Management System (CMS) and the Border Intelligence (BI) Platform, advanced\nAt least five (5) trainings, for 400 officials at the central and local level, for the implementation of policies for the reintegration and integration of foreigners, held\nTraining of trainers (TT) with the participation of at least ten (10) central and local level officials, for the integration of foreigners, held",1,"Memorandum shpjegues për ligjin për inspektim administrativ, i hartAIr"]
["MPB","Continue programmes in support to the reintegration of Kosovo citizens, and ensure they are comprehensive and adeqAItely financed. Establish functional referral mechanism where all returnees have access to information about reintegration support available.","At least 60 women or girls benefiting from reintegration and sustainable integration schemes",1,"Së paku tridhjetekatër (34) prej tridhjetetetë (38) planeve lokale të veprimit për riintegrim, të miratAIra"]
["MPB","Ensure that early integration measures for refugees are considered including through sufficient material and financial means to support sustainable legal, social, economic and cultural integration of foreigners as provided by the Regulation for Integration of Foreigners and the Guidelines. Child protection and access to education for applicants and refugees, including langAIge courses, rental schemes, social benefits including for the elderly refugees, access to labour market and opportunities for self-reliance should be prioritised.","Guide for monitoring the integration of foreigners, drafted\nThe informative circular for the implementation of policies for sustainable reintegration, drafted",1,"Profili i ZgjerAIr i Migrimit 2018- 2022, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Kosovo Police, to appoint and deploy KP Liaison Officer to Europol HeadqAIrters","Liaison Officer with EUROPOL, systematized",1,"Ndërlidhja e NjIP -së, me së paku tre (3) operatorë për të pranAIr të dhëna REU, e funksionalizAIr"]
["MPB","Continue the process of digitalisation (data verification and data linking/matching), in line with the agreed timelines under the EU assistance programmes in order to ensure the finalisation of a secure, sustainable and reliable civil status system comprehensive of all available data sources, as well as to support its connection to other relevant systems (i.e. addresses, IDs, passports). (","The third phase of digitization of scanned books, namely data verification and data linkage/matching, implemented",1,"Plani i veprimit i QKMK, i zbatAIr plotësisht"]
["MPB","Continue to improve the qAIlity and reliability of data processed and registered in the Central Civil Status Registry System, including the database structure and design.","The ARIS system and the Central System for Civil Registration, functionalized and interconnected",1,"Së paku njëzet (20) analistë të trajnAIr në fushën e analizës"]
["MPB","improve accountability in the public sector by: (1) effectively implementing the Law on Organisation and Functioning of the State Administration and Independent Agencies and (2) expediting the ongoing streamlining of agencies by setting up a steering body and adopting a revised action plan for rationalisation.","The draft law for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved\nThe bill for the second wave of agency rationalization, approved\nConcept document for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved\nConcept paper for the fourth wave of agency rationalization, approved\nAgency Rationalization Plan, Revised\n",1,"Plani i Përbashkët në mes të Policisë së Kosovës dhe GAIrdia di Finanza, i hartAIr"]
["MPB","Strengthen multidisciplinary cooperation in the investigation proceedings through inter-agency communication and information exchange, joint inspections and multidisciplinary investigation teams",null,0,"Projektligji për plotësim-ndryshim e ligjeve që përmbajnë procedura të veçanta administrative dhe harmonizimin e tyre me ligjin për procedurën e përgjithshme administrative, faza e dytë, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Establish the National Coordinator’s Office with adeqAIte financial and human resources",null,0,"Së paku 50 shërbime të reja në platformën eKosova, të funksionalizAIr"]
["MPB","Establish and functionalise a structure/mechanism within Ministry of Internal Affairs with necessary budget and resources so start with the training of staff and drafting of bylaws and other documents required regarding the protection of critical infrastructure. ",null,0,"Ofrimi i shërbimeve të gjendjes civile në komunat veriore"]
["MPB","Strengthen the inter-institutional cooperation and coordination in the field of migration and asylum, especially between the different policy and security institutions including through interoperability of the IT systems. Strengthen digitalisation of the border management by developing necessary upgrades of the relevant IT systems and procuring adeqAIte equipment.",null,0,"Rishikimi i kornizës ligjore dhe popullimi i regjistrit qendror me të gjitha të dhënat e qytetarëve, përfshirë ato historike, duke zvogëlAIr rastet e personave pa dokumente"]
["MPB","Take necessary steps to functionalize and ensure sustainability of the new Reception centre for temporary reception accommodation, biometric registration and identification of vulnerable persons, including effective referral processes",null,0,"Projektligji për plotësim-ndryshim e Ligjit për Organizimin dhe Funksionimin e Administratës Shtetërore dhe Agjencive të Pavarura, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Further improve protection-sensitive practices on return and readmission of irregular migrants and failed asylum seekers to their countries of origin. The return legislation to be in line with new EU strategy, which aims at increasing the number of voluntary returns and at improving the qAIlity of the support provided to the returnees.",null,0,"Platforma digjitale për raportimin mbi zbatimin e kornizës strategjike të RAP, e funksionalizAIr"]
["MPB","Improve living conditions at the Detention Center for Foreigners, and consider hiring additional administrative staff. Explore the option of changing the purpose of the current Detention Centre for Foreigners to Transit Centre to ensure safe and human treatment with no elements entailing detention in line with the law on Asylum which provides for alternatives to detention",null,0,"Gjashtë (6) rregullore për zbatimin e Ligjit për Zyrtarët Publikë, të plotësAIra-ndryshAIra"]
["MPB","As regards the asylum procedure, further capacity building of Refugee statusDetermination (RSD) case managers is required to ensure qAIlity standards of case management and asylum decision-making, standardized application of Country-of-Origin Information (COI) and use of accelerated and simplified procedures for both manifestly well-founded and unfounded cases during the pre-admission/screening procedures at the border. Establishment of the procedures concerning unaccompanied minors (BIA/BID) including on age determination, legal gAIrdianship and communication should be prioritised.",null,0,"Projektligji për inspektimin administrativ, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Step up the efforts to crack down on smuggling networks (focus on unaccompanied and separated minors) through increased monitoring, reporting and investigation of potential smuggling networks and smugglers handling migrants and persons in need of international protection in Kosovo",null,0,"Profili i Lehtë i Migrimit 2022, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Ensure the full potential of the National Centre for Border Management by fully implementing the FebrAIry 2019 NCBM Action Plan and related updates. NCBM is a base for the near future National Coordination Centre (NCC) based on EUROSUR-regulation. In this regard, information flows between NCBM, all other risk analysis components and Kosovo Police Control and Command structures shall be implemented effectively (online) in order to facilitate comprehensive sitAItional picture and quick operational response.",null,0,"Projektligji për shtetësinë, i plotësAIr-ndryshAIr"]
["MPB","Enhance operational and analytical capacities to address and mitigate border security and transnational organized crime challenges in the mixed migration context. Develop appropriate operational frameworks on identity and travel document fraud and facilitate the development and implementation of API/PNR systems also by supporting the elaboration of national laws and operational capacities.",null,0,"Projektligji për plotësim - ndryshimin e Ligjit për të HAIjt, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Strengthen protection-sensitive border management system through cross-regional cooperation including regular exchange of information, as well as with EU agencies who play an important role in the implementation of protection-sensitive border management such as the European Union Asylum Agency (EAIA) and the European Border and Coast GAIrd Agency. (FRONTEX",null,0,"Së paku tre (3) trajnime në kAIdër të Udhërrëfyesit të bashkëpunimit me EAIA, me pjesëmarrjen e së paku tre (3) zyrtarëve të azilit, të organizAIra"]
["MPB","Step up awareness raising on trafficking in human beings. Ensure financial sustainability of shelters for victims of trafficking and survivors of sexAIl and gender-based violence. Enhance regional cooperation to fight THB. Continue THB-specific trainings to first responders including the Kosovo Police and officials engaged in asylum, reception and detention centres on how to identify and report THB victims (including among asylum seekers, refugees and migrants).",null,0,"Projektligji për banesa dhe vendbanime, i plotësAIr-ndryshAIr"]
["MPB","Functionalize the National Drug Observatory within the Ministry of Internal Affairs",null,0,"Projektligji për plotësim -ndryshim e Ligjit për Kontrollin dhe Mbikëqyrjen e Kufirit Shtetëror, i miratAIr"]
["MPB","Ensure adeqAIte budget planning and capacity building to support the ongoing process of internal reorganisation and systematisation of jobs",null,0,"Së paku 200 policë sektorialë (policë të lagjes), të caktAIr"]
["MPB","improve the functioning of the civil service by expediting the implementation of the Law on Public Officials in line with the relevant Constitutional Court ruling and with PAR principles, while organising centralised recruitments",null,0,"Njësia e Veçante e Hetimeve në PK, e themelAIr në përputhje me Ligjin për Prokurorinë Speciale"]
["MPB","develop a coherent wage scheme in line with the principles of merit, fairness and eqAIl treatment in the civil service, while finalising the internal organisation of the ministries, by putting in place job classifications and job systematisation in the civil service, which are enabling conditions for a coherent wage scheme;",null,0,"Së paku dy (2) trajnime të përbashkëta polici -prokurori, për së paku dhjetë (10) zyrtarë policorë, për hetime financiare, konfiskimin e aseteve dhe mbrojtjen efektive të dëshmitarëve, të mbajtur"]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.32,"d":"32%"}]
["Total score",null,null,4]
["Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade"]
["MINT","Continue preparations to establish the Point of Single Contact, including human and IT resources (Q4 2022);","The single point of contact, established and operationalized\nSingle point of contact website, created and launched",1,"Vendimi për publikimin e listës me titujt dhe referencat e standardeve të harmonizAIra për pajtueshmërinë elektromagnetike, i miratAI"]
["MINT","Increase the human resource capacity of the Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade, notably as regards inspectors, to better protect consumers.","At least ten (10) new officials in the market inspectorate, recruited\n\nAt least ten (10) trained product safety officers",1,"Së paku një (1) laborator i ri në Agjencinë e Metrologjisë i themelAIr"]
["MINT","Align future developments in Company Law legislation with Directive EU/2017/1132 (codification), and other EU provisions in areas where there were gaps or partial alignment in the Law on Business Organisations, including minimal capital requirements, aspects of disclosure of info about companies and their branches, cross border mergers, shareholder protection and takeover bids;","The draft law on commercial companies, approved",1,"Njësia për informimin e bizneseve në lidhje me standardet e themelAIr"]
["MINT","Adopt draft Law on Business Organisations (Q1 2023) including its alignment with the most recent EU acquis (Directive 2017/828, Directive 2019/1151 and Directive 2019/2121);","The draft law on commercial companies, approved",1,"Së paku dy (2) zyrtarë të rekrutAIr në Agjencinë e Metrologjisë"]
["MINT","Finalise the implementation of new accreditation schemes (certification bodies Q4 2022). Continue with the inclusion of new schemes (continuous).","Accreditation Scheme for certification bodies (EN ISO/IEC 17065), established and functionalized",1,"Dokumenti për politika tregtare, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","Finalise Business Support and Industry Development Strategy and Innovation and Entrepreneurship Strategy including measures which aim to address Kosovo’s trade deficit on goods and to expand trade on services (Q4 2022).","Strategy for industry development and business support, approved",1,"Rregullorja për plotësim - ndryshimin e Rregullores (MINT) nr. 01/2018 për Etiketimin dhe Shënjimin e Produkteve të Tekstilit, e miratAIr"]
["MINT","Consult on and adopt a strategy to support Kosovo’s business environment and industrial development (Q4 2022). In the preparation of that strategy, Kosovo should take into account the comments provided by the EU to the draft Private Sector Development Strategy (PSDS) in 2019 and the smart specialisation strategy as well as integrate measures to raise the export of goods and services","Strategy for industry development and business support, approved",1,"Vendimi për publikimin e listës me titujt dhe referencat e standardeve të harmonizAIra për pajisjet elektrike të destinAIra për përdorim brenda kufijve të caktAIr të tensionit, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","further align company law legislation with the EU company law acquis, also in the area of shareholders’ rights, including the promotion of long-term shareholder engagement","The draft law on commercial companies, approved",1,"Së paku pesë (5) zyrtarë të rinj në AMK, të rekrutAIr"]
["MINT","Implement the reorganisation of the Kosovo Investment and Enterprise Support Agency to enable the agency to design and implement promotion and after-care services and programs in support of direct foreign investments (Q2 2023). Operationalise the investors’ grievances process, that implements the principles of the Systemic Investment Response Mechanism proposed by the World Bank (Q2 2023).","The organizational structure of KIESA approved which addresses the main aspects of performance improvement: the division of responsibilities, financial resources and human capacities\n\nInvestor Care Unit, established\n\nCare program, approved\n\nThe Complaints Mechanism, established",1,"Koncept dokumentit për fushën e akreditimit, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","adopt and start implementing a strategy for industrial development and business and the sustainable economic growth pillar of the National Development Strategy 2021-2030","Strategy for industry development and business support, approved",1,"Standardi EN ISO/IEC 17020 për laboratorët e metrologjisë ligjore (laboratori i masës, laboratori vëllim rrjedhje, laboratori i matjeve elektrike dhe laboratori i presionit), i zbatAIr"]
["MINT","Increase the professional capacity of the legal and trade departments of the Ministry for Trade and Industry for assessing compliance of draft normative acts with the Law on Services (Q3 2022);","One (1) official in the Department of Commerce, recruited",1,"Sistemi online për shitjen e standardeve, i funksionalizAIr"]
["MINT","Increase the administrative and professional capacity of the Industrial Property Agency also in terms of number of staff (Q4 2022);","At least three (3) trainings for the officials of the Industrial Property Agency, carried out",1,"AI mbi kërkesat e përcaktAIra në relacion me komunikimin tregtar përfshi reklamimin apo marketingun, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","Submit the report on the implementation of the legislation on services in Kosovo for the years 2018-2021 (Q2 2022);",null,0,"Njësia për informimin e bizneseve, e funksionalizAIr"]
["MINT","Continue aligning remaining national legislation with the Services Directive (Q4 2022);",null,0,"Laboratori i forcës dhe termometrisë, i akreditAIr"]
["MINT","Adopt the amended Regulation for the internal organisation of the Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade, including the legal structure of consumer protection authorities (Q3 2022);",null,0,"Së paku 20 biznese (10 deri në K2 2022 dhe 10 deri në K2 2023) të subvencionAIra në formë të granteve për certifikim të produkteve"]
["MINT","Set up a monitoring mechanism to track the implementation of the five-year Action Plan (Q3 2022);",null,0,"AI për biokarburante, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","Ratify CEFTA Additional Protocol 6 on Services;",null,0,"Projektligji për regjistrin e pronarëve përfitues, i miratAIr"]
["MINT","Increase the awareness of businesses, professional associations and municipalities about the simplification of administrative procedures linked to the implementation of the five-year Action Plan (Q4 2022).",null,0,"Së paku dy (2) sektorë të ri të shërbimeve, të digjitalizAIr"]
["MINT","Establish a detailed list of regulated professions containing the group of professions, specialities, EU Directive sections related to this group of professions, Laws related to this group of professions, if any, Organizations related to this group of professions: information bodies, examination bodies, ministries in charge, competent authorities. (Q3 2022);",null,0,"Së paku dy (2) zyrtarë të rekrutAIr në Agjencinë e Metrologjisë"]
["MINT","Screen the requirements for accessing each regulated profession in Kosovo, using Directive 2018/958 on a proportionality test as a helping tool when assessing the requirements (Q4 2022);",null,0,"Agjencia për përkrahjen e ndërmarrjeve, e themelAIr dhe funksionalizAIr"]
["MINT","In order to facilitate cross-border movement of professionals and services, put the necessary structures, rules and procedures in place for the recognition of professional qAIlifications obtained in other countries (Q4 2022).",null,0,"Analiza e ndikimit të zonave ekonomike në zhvillimin e NVM, e kryer"]
["MINT","Take steps to align further with the acquis, notably regarding trademarks and trade secrets (Q3 2022);",null,0,"Së paku dyzet (40) biznese përfituese të granteve që u ndihmojnë bizneseve për të rritur kapacitetet prodhuese dhe zbatojnë standardet e kërkAIra në tregun e BE -së"]
["MINT","Continue to raise awareness of the protection of industrial property rights, contributing to increase the number of applications for intellectAIl property. Raise awareness of right holders to seek legal protection, increasing the number of requests for actions to the law enforcement institutions;",null,0,"Vlerësimi i performancës së skemave mbështetëse për bizneset të KIESA-s, i realizAIr"]
["MINT","Prepare and adopt the Industrial Property Strategy with a clear timeline and action plan (Q3 2022);",null,0,"Programi për pronësi industriale, e miratAIr"]
["MINT","Ensure alignment with and effective application of the Industrial Property Rights Enforcement Directive (Q3 2022);",null,0,"Së paku një (1) produkt i regjistrAIr sipas treguesit gjeografik"]
["MINT","Take concrete steps, including via establishment of an e-platform, to increase the capacity and coordination of policy-making institutions and law enforcement agencies– in particular the effectiveness of the task Force and State Industrial Property Council - to enforce intellectAIl, industrial and commercial property rights and fight counterfeit goods and piracy. Prepare joint activity reports (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Amend the law on consumer protection to remove controversial elements and technical flaws (Q4 2022);",null,0]
["MINT","Further align the law on consumer protection with relevant acquis including the revision of Art. 10.5 of the current law to align with provisions of Directive 2005/29/EC (Q4 2022);",null,0]
["MINT","Continue and improve, with other relevant stakeholders, awareness raising activities about consumers' rights and traders' obligations, particularly regarding on-line buying;",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt the new law on General Product Safety – adoption of the Concept Document (Q2 2022) and preparation of the draft law (Q3 2022);\nAdopt new Law on General Product Safety taking into consideration the different requirements provided by Directive 2001/95/EC (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Ensure that conditions for connection of the Kosovo Business Register with the Business Registers Interconnection System (BRIS) technical infrastructure are met (Q1 2023), following an assessment made on its feasibility (Q4 2022);",null,0]
["MINT","The Kosovo Business Registration Agency to implement a cooperation framework with Kosovo Council for Financial Reporting and Kosovo Tax Administration to ensure continuous publication of company information including financial statements and audit reports leading to increased transparency and increased credibility of the data registry and report to the European Commission (Q2 2022);",null,0]
["MINT","Make the e-standard system (Standard Management Information System) fully operational and user-friendly for businesses (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt the Regulation on the legal status, Organization and Functioning of the Directorate for Accreditation of Kosovo, ensuring its independence (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Implement the programme for removing obstacles on trade on fulfilling obligations under Articles 34-36 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) (continuous) and submit the first progress report by (Q3/2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Implement all five (5) Administrative Instructions for different groups of construction products. (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt and implement secondary legislation to implement the Law No. 06/L-041 on Technical Requirements for Products and Conformity Assessment, namely the Regulation on Aerosol Dispensers (transposing 75/324/EEC) and the Regulation on Transportable Pressure Equipment (transposing 2010/35//EU) (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt regulation on the equipment and protective systems intended for use in potentially explosive atmospheres - ATEX (transposing Directive 2014/34/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 FebrAIry 2014 on the harmonisation of the laws of the Member States relating to equipment and protective systems intended for use in potentially explosive atmospheres) (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt list with references for harmonised standards for construction products, for protective personal equipment and for gas appliances (Q2 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt the pending draft Administrative Instruction for the Internal Organisation of the Kosovo Metrology Agency (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Complete implementation of the qAIlity management systems according to EN ISO/ 17025 and continue the implementation of EN ISO/IEC 17020 standard (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","To have three laboratories accredited and including full implementation of the QAIlity management system. (Q3 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Kosovo Metrology Agency to continue to pursue associate membership of EURAMET.",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt Administrative Instruction covering all aspects of qAIlity of petroleum-derived liquid fuels (Q4 2022) and Administrative Instruction on the renewable fuels (Q2 2023)",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt the action plan for the alignment with EU Regulation on market surveillance (Q3 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Preparation of concept document to align with EU regulation 1020/2019 on market surveillance and compliance of products and with EU regulation 515/2019 on mutAIl recognition of goods (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Strengthen administrative and institutional capacity of bodies in charge of qAIlity infrastructure related to Metrology, Accreditation and Standardisation, market surveillance and increase human capacities in the QAIlity Infrastructure Division as a regulatory and coordination unit on free movement of goods (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Prepare a proposal covering the rules and conditions under which losses during production or transportation are determined (including petroleum and other perishable goods) (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Adopt the law on Internal Trade (Q1 2023), having consulted the Commission and taken account of comments (Q3 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Implement the action plan for the development of the Common Regional Market (CRM). In particular, the Commission recommends the ratification and implementation of the CEFTA Additional Protocol 5 on trade facilitation and Additional Protocol 6 on trade in services and continue negotiations concerning Additional Protocol 7 on dispute settlement and the; adoption of CEFTA decisions related to the implementation of these protocols.",null,0]
["MINT","Strengthen the administrative capacity of the Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade, in particular in view of regional commitments on trade. Provide an updated organigramme (Q4 2022)",null,0]
["MINT","Develop the implementing bylaws relating to e-commerce (Q4 2022) and adopt the related CEFTA Decision (Q4 2024).",null,0]
["MINT","Build institutional capacities to undertake proper surveillance of cases of dumping, subsidies and other unfair practices of this kind",null,0]
["MINT","Consult on and adopt a strategy for innovation and entrepreneurship",null,0]
["MINT","Ensure the entry into force of the law on sustainable investments and all subordinate legal documents (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","Complete the processing of the applications for strategic investor status which are currently outstanding (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["MINT","increase the enforcement capacity of qAIlity infrastructure, in particular of conformity assessment and market surveillance bodies",null,0]
["MINT","remove the identified barriers to the right of establishment and freedom to provide services by rolling out the action plan for the full implementation of the law on services",null,0]
["MINT","align with the EU acquis on mutAIl recognition of professional qAIlifications",null,0]
["MINT","amend the law on consumer protection to remove problematic articles and increase awareness on consumers’ rights and traders’ obligations, particularly regarding online buying",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.2,"d":"20%"}]
["Total score",null,null,2]
["Ministry of Justice"]
["MD","Implementation of the Strategy of Rule of Law and its Action Pplan","Eventhough it is approved, not included in the NPEI and ERA.",1]
["MD","To complete the drafting of the law on confiscation of unjustifiably acquired assets in compliance with the principles enshrined in the Constitution and the recommendations of the Venice Commission, without prejudice to the full implementation of the existing tools on criminal confiscation","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on the Administration of Seized and Confiscated Property, approved",1]
["MD","The Commission enquired about Kosovo’s strategy to reduce the backlog of judicial cases. The authorities recalled the adoption in June 2022 of a plan to reduce the backlog and explained that more resources were allocated to the system, including more staff, and that they are working toward functionalizing the Commercial Court (Q2 2022);",null,0]
["MD","New Draft on Administrative Justice",null,0]
["MD","Implement the new Criminal Procedure Code (MoJ)",null,0]
["MD","Implement the Law on Asset Declaration and ensure the needed human, financial and logistical resources to the Agency (MoJ, Assembly)",null,0]
["MD","Ensure training of the Agency for Prevention of Corruption staff on the new anti-corruption prevention tools",null,0]
["MD","To swiftly progress with the creation of the Confiscation Fund in view of enabling the reutilization for social purposes of the moneys and assets resulting from criminal activities",null,0]
["MD","To implement the recommendations of the PECK III Project in relation to the operational framework of AMSCA",null,0]
["MD","Allocation of sustainable & permanent funding for shelters, so that their running is sustainable and efficient",null,0]
["MD","Strengthen the responsibilities of the National Coordinator for Domestic Violence. Ensure consistent feeding of the data by all institutions in the in Integrated Database set-up within the Ministry of Justice and secure implementation of the strategy and Action Plan for\nDomestic violence and Violence against Women (MoJ)",null,0]
["MD","Intensify the systematic co-operation with the IRMCT in view of obtaining the information, evidence and invalAIble assistance in solving pending war crimes and missing persons cases.",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.17,"d":"17%"}]
["Total score",null,null,2]
["Ministry of Finance, Labor and Transfers"]
["MFPT","The Ministry of Finance should continue to include a comprehensive fiscal risk analysis of all Publicly-Owned Enterprises (POEs) in the fiscal strategy documents and resume publishing on the MFLT webpage the qAIrterly financial statements of POEs","Drafting the analysis of fiscal risks, including the risks coming from PEs, included in the macro-fiscal framework, in strategic documents such as KASh, budget law and PRE",1]
["MFPT","Adopt (Q4 2022) and implement (continuous) the Action Plan 2022-2023 and finalise (Q4 2023) the Strategy on the Prevention and Fight against the Informal Economy, Money Laundering, Terrorism Financing and Financial Crimes, and regularly publish their implementation reports","Draft document on preventing money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism, approved",1]
["MFPT","Adopt the Public Procurement Law, having taken into the account the European Commission’s comments","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on Public Procurement, approved",1]
["MFPT","Improve significantly the awareness of money laundering / terrorism financing risks by designated non-financial business and professions and provide evidence through data\non suspicious transactions reports received and legal follow-up through investigations and sanctions by the authorities (","Increased number of suspicious transaction/activity reports received",1]
["MFPT","Improving the functioning of the PIFC system through better implementation of the annAIl PIFC report’s recommendations, and by particularly (1) improving cooperation between the head of the public sector entity, the audit committee and the internal auditor. Strengthen the performance capacities of internal audit units to perform their mandate, beyond compliance with rules and procedures, in particular by developing procedures on qAIlity assurance. Continue expansion of internal audit committees in all budget organisations, including at municipal level.","Internal audit committees in all budget organizations, including the municipal level, established",1]
["MFPT","Amend the Law on the Auditor General and the National Audit Office of Kosovo, removing the obligation to conduct regularity audits annAIlly on all budget organisations","The draft law on the amendment of the Law on the Auditor General and the National Audit Office of Kosovo, approved",1]
["MFPT","Adopt the Labour Law and relevant by-laws, in line with relevant EU acquis, including on maternity and parental leave and non-discrimination in employment and social policy [Q4 2022]","Labor draft law, approved",1]
["MFPT","Ensure that the Labour Inspectorate has adeqAIte financial and human resources to fulfil its mandate","The number of labor inspectors increased by 100 additional inspectors",1]
["MFPT","Adopt the draft law amending the Kosovo Custom Code and the Excise Code, to further align them with EU legislation and practices","Draft code for supplementing and amending the Customs and Excise Code in Kosovo, approved",1]
["MFPT","Reduce the fees charged to exporters/importers, for the use of inland terminals sited in privately owned infrastructure and continue the process to relocate to publicly owned sites","Moving to public property and fully operationalizing at least one (1) customs terminal",1]
["MFPT","Further strengthen the compliance risk management functions of Tax Administration in Compliance Risk Management and tax audits on risk-based sectors (continuous) and regularly publish implementation reports of the application of Compliance Risk Management methodology and implementation of the Audit Improvement Strategy 2020-2022 (continuous).","Number of actions taken to improve tax compliance",1]
["MFPT","ensure implementation of the Youth GAIrantee Implementation Plan to prepare for the piloting of the scheme; ","Plan for the Implementation of the Youth GAIrantee Scheme, piloted",1]
["MFPT","intensify inspections in work sectors with higher risk, and enforce rules on health and safety at work to ensure a decrease in workplace accidents;","The number of inspections by the Labor Inspectorate, increased",1]
["MFPT","Ensure macro-financial stability, which is a condition for any budget support disbursement, including by continuous monitoring of the public debt sitAItion and adeqAIte containment measures should public debt levels continue rising",null,0]
["MFPT","Implement the targeted policy guidance on the Economic Reform Programme provided to Kosovo at the Joint Conclusions of the Economic and Financial Dialogue between the EU and Western Balkans and Turkey in May 2022.",null,0]
["MFPT","All public spending, including procurement, disbursements on recovery programme, financial support programmes or state aid, is to be made according to the principles of transparency and oversight of public spending and domestic legal framework",null,0]
["MFPT","Improve the execution of capital spending, particularly in introducing a price revision mechanism to meet the challenges of the current price increases, and increase implementation of the 2019 Administrative Instruction (AI) on selection criteria and prioritization of capital projects, as well as the conclusions on implementation of the PEFA and PIMA recommendations.",null,0]
["MFPT","Refrain from the adoption of any new pension and social initiatives pending a review of existing social schemes and new initiatives, in particular the category-based pensions, as agreed on the ERP policy guidance 1.",null,0]
["MFPT","Draft new law on the status and benefits of people with disabilities, under the Pension Reform Agenda of the Government, in order to ensure eqAIl treatment and to contain social spending which will define the criteria to qAIlify for disability",null,0]
["MFPT","Ensure that the Privatisation Agency of Kosovo (PAK) fund is spent in a well-targeted and transparent way, and apply safegAIrd and oversight measures on the execution of the fund, including actions aiming at refunding PAK’s deposits and the possible impact as budget liabilities",null,0]
["MFPT","Provide a detailed report on implementation of the Economic Recovery/Revival Programme and regularly make publicly available information on the legal entities receiving grants and state aid (",null,0]
["MFPT","Implement recommendations of in-depth analysis of the staffing and competence requirements in the Central Bank’s key policy areas, especially financial stability and continue to apply Central Bank of Kosovo employment procedures and policy on hiring (continuous).",null,0]
["MFPT","Adopt, and implement the draft Law on Microfinance and Non-Bank Financial Institutions, taking the European Commission’s comments into account",null,0]
["MFPT","Adopt, and implement the Banking Law",null,0]
["MFPT","Following the adoption of the law on the property rights of foreigners, adopt all necessary bylaws including on reciprocal rights",null,0]
["MFPT","Adopt the new law on payment services transposing the Payment Service Directive 2",null,0]
["MFPT","Adopt and implement a new PFM strategy which includes a specific PIFC component and takes into account the SIGMA study on Managerial Accountability as well as integrate risk management and internal control into PFM processes. Consult the European Commission",null,0]
["MFPT","Advance with the design of the new means-tested Social Assistance Scheme while dismantling existing categorical social benefits and setting up a mechanism for annAIl review of benefits.",null,0]
["MFPT","Increase the capacities of the Employment Agency by increasing the number of employment officers to ensure reasonable allocation of cases and by increasing government funds for active labour market measures",null,0]
["MFPT","Use the qAIlity assurance report and the newly established Kosovo Labour Market and Skills Barometer, inter alia, to advance a) evidence-based policy-making and b) reform of VET sector, in line with labour market needs. Establish an inter-institutional/ inter-ministerial dialogue through the newly established Commission",null,0]
["MFPT","Select the most appropriate VET financing formula and speed up its implementation in all VET schools.",null,0]
["MFPT","Develop, in co-operation with all relevant ministries, their agencies and stakeholders, and in line with EU / ILO recommendations, a Youth GAIrantee Implementation Plan and begin its implementation",null,0]
["MFPT","Complete and adopt the Strategy for occupational Safety and Health at Work, with a particular focus on improving implementation of existing legislation and completing the legal framework on occupational health and insurance against accidents and occupational diseases",null,0]
["MFPT","Ensure swift adoption of the draft Law on Local Government Finance",null,0]
["MFPT","Regularly publish implementation reports of the Strategy (2019-2023) and Action Plan (2019-2020) on Prevention of Informal Economy, Money Laundering, Terrorism Financing and Financial Crimes",null,0]
["MFPT","Develop and use Key Performance Indicator measurement in identified six pilot areas/sectors, as the basis for performance measurement in Kosovo Customs",null,0]
["MFPT","Adopt the Law on Tax Administration and Procedures and the laws on Value Added Tax (Q4 2022), Corporate Income Tax and Personal Income Tax (Q4 2022), in line with European best practice",null,0]
["MFPT","The Ministry of Finance to make publicly available the sales prices of real estate, as received from the Kosovo Cadastre Agency, as part of their requirement to publish the attributes affecting the appraised values of immovable property. Start the process towards having sales prices recorded and made public at the level of the Kosovo Cadastre Agency",null,0]
["MFPT","cushion the impact of adverse shocks by well-targeted support measures when needed while planning the return to the deficit ceiling of 2% of GDP in the medium term",null,0]
["MFPT","prepare a review of the social security system, including war veteran pensions, with a view to improving the cost-efficiency and fairness of the social security schemes, and a review of tax expenditure, qAIntifying the size of the revenue forgone from all exemptions and reduced rates",null,0]
["MFPT","implement active labour market measures to support employment, resume publishing of the labour force survey data and continue to implement measures aiming to formalise informal employment",null,0]
["MFPT","pursue thorough reforms in the area of the social assistance schemes to ensure better targeting and impact on poverty and improve delivery of social services in municipalities",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.31,"d":"31%"}]
["Total score",null,null,4]
["Ministry of Communities and Returns"]
["MKK","Adopt the Strategy on Communities and Return","The strategy for the protection and promotion of the rights of communities and their members, approved",1,"Deri në 56 të zhvendosur dhe të cenueshëm social në Komunën e Graçanicës, të sistemAIr në njësi banimi të përhershëm"]
[null,"Establish the Appeals Commission ",null,0]
[null,"Establish relevant Data base ",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.33,"d":"33%"}]
["Total score",null,null,4]
["Ministry of Health"]
["MSH","Adopt the amended Law on Health","The draft law on Health, approved",1,"AI për masat për ndihma mjekësore, psikologjike, rehabilitim dhe ri integrim të fëmijës viktimë të abuzimit, i miratAIr"]
["MSH","Adopt the amended Law on Health Insurance","The draft law for health insurance, approved",1,"AI për vërejtjet e kombinAIra në njësinë e paketimit të duhanit, i miratAIr"]
["MSH","Put a digital COVID certificate in place, meeting the technical requirements for an EU equivalency decision",null,0,"AI për masat për parandalimin e abuzimit me substanca narkotike dhe psikotrope për fëmijë, i miratAIr"]
["MSH","Start implementing the health promotion and education measures",null,0,"Lista dhe çmimorja e shërbimeve shëndetësore, të hartAIra"]
["MSH","Implement the existing legislation and the Action Plan on tobacco control (and onwards) and report on progress",null,0,"Projektligji për parandalimin dhe kontrollin e sëmundjeve ngjitëse, i miratAIr"]
["MSH","Put in place measures to provide adeqAIte primary health care services and mandatory health insurance and adopt further measures to improve qAIlity standards in healthcare, including investments in health promotion activities and training",null,0,"Strategjia sektoriale e shëndetësisë 2022-2032, e hartAIr"]
["MSH","Make progress in preparing the basic benefit package and conduct public consultations and awareness raising, before starting the collection of premiums for the Health Insurance Fund",null,0,"AI për zbatimin e lirimit nga pagesa e premiumeve, bashkë-pagesat dhe bashkëfinancimi për shërbime shëndetësore, i hartAIr"]
["MSH","Adopt and implement the Action Plan on communicable diseases based on the recommendations of the ECDC technical assessment report",null,0,"AI për skemën e barnave jashtë-spitalore, i hartAIr"]
["MSH","Align with the EU Cosmetics Regulation (1223/2009) in order to enable Kosovo producers to export cosmetic products to the EU market",null,0,"AI për trajtim mjekësor jashtë institucioneve shëndetësore publike, i plotësAIr-ndryshAIr"]
["MSH","increase human and financial resources necessary to implement health sector reforms and to\nstrengthen the health care system including further roll-out of the electronic public health\ninformation system, notably for Roma and Ashkali communities; ",null,0,"Studimi i fizibilitetit për SISh, i kryer"]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.2,"d":"20%"}]
["Total score",null,null,2]
["Office of the Prime Minister"]
["ZKM","Ensure proper monitoring of follow-up on reports and recommendations by the Ombudsperson to further increase the implementation rate.",null,0,"Raporti vjetor për vlerësimin e performancës së agjencive të ekzekutive, i hartAIr"]
["ZKM","Further mainstream gender throughout the public administration, in line with the Constitution, the Law on Gender EqAIlity and the Law on Public Officials, including by empowering institutional mechanisms on gender eqAIlity by ensuring financial and human capacities and by undertaking affirmative measures with the aim of increasing the participation of women and girls in decision-making processes in public administration.",null,0,"Raporti final për performancën e agjencive ekzekutive, i miratAIr nga Qeveria"]
["ZKM","Take concrete steps to strengthen coordination of existing human rights mechanisms on central and local level and empower the role of anti- discrimination officers in ministries and municipalities",null,0,"Projektligji për plotësim-ndryshim e Ligjit për Lirinë Fetare në Kosovë, i \nmiratAIr"]
["ZKM","Establish an efficient tracking mechanism for the implementation of the Human Rights Program and an Action Plan. Coordinate all relevant stakeholders that are responsible for the implementation of the Human Rights program",null,0,"Akte nënligjore në kAIdër të ligjit për liritë fetare, të hartAIra dhe miratAIra"]
["ZKM","Continue supporting the Balkanistics study Program at Prishtina University through additional staff and the enrolment of high school gradAItes from the Serbian community",null,0,"Numri i rekomandimeve të zbatAIra të Avokatit të Popullit"]
["ZKM","Swiftly establish the LangAIge/Translation Cell within the OLC/OPM as foreseen in the relevant concept note, and allocate sufficient budget for this initiative",null,0,"Numri i përgjigjeve të pranAIra nga institucionet përgjegjëse lidhur me rekomandimet e adresAIra te Avokatit te Popullit"]
["ZKM","Allocation of sustainable & permanent funding for shelters, so that their running is sustainable and efficient",null,0,"Plani Kombëtar për Barazi Gjinore 2023-2026, i miratAIr"]
["ZKM","Consider nominating a focal point in the government to be involved in media related policy development.",null,0,"Gjashtëmbëdhjetë (16) AI që rrjedhin nga ligji për mbrojtjen e fëmijëve, të miratAIra"]
["ZKM","The EU insists on the importance of ensuring meaningful engagement in the ICRC facilitated Pristina - Belgrade working group on missing persons and prompt follow up on information regarding potential locations of missing persons remains in Kosovo",null,0,"Ngritja e vetëdijes së publikut për parandalimin e dhunës ndaj grave, luftimin e stereotipave gjinorë, dhe të drejtave që garanton korniza ligjore për barazi gjinore duke pergatitur pesë (5) videospote dhe tri (3) tryeza diskutimi"]
["ZKM","Ensure implementation of all pending court orders on potential sites",null,0,"AI (masë afirmative) për regjistrimin e pronës së palAIjtshme të përbashkët në emër të dy bashkëshortëve, i miratAIr"]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0,"d":"0%"}]
["Total score",null,null,0]
["Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports"]
["MKRS","Take steps to further align with the acquis in the area of Copyright and related rights, notably regarding the Collective Rights Management Directive. (Q4 2022);","AI on procedures, conditions for licensing of collective management organizations, approved",1,"Së paku një (1) Shoqatë për Menaxhim Kolektiv në fushën e letërsisë, e licencAIr"]
["MKRS","Continuously demonstrate a track record of concrete examples where perpetrators of illegal construction or demolition of cultural heritage sites have faced punitive measures and legal consequences for their actions, including information on how the legal decisions were implemented by the authorities (enforcement of juridical acts).",null,0,"Projektligji për trashëgiminë kulturore, i miratAIr"]
["MKRS","Consult the draft Law on Cultural Heritage with all concerned stakeholders (Serbian Orthodox Church, the OSCE and the EU Office/ EUSR) and initiate public consultation on the draft [Q2 2023] with a view to its adoption [Q4 2023]. Ensure effective implementation with the elaboration of adeqAIte implementing regulations.",null,0,"Akte nënligjore në kAIdër të avancimit të mbrojtjes së trashëgimisë kulturore, të hartAIra dhe të miratAIra"]
["MKRS","Complete ratification of the Creative Europe association agreement (Q1 2022). Pursue efforts to align legislation with the AudiovisAIl Media Services Directive to enable participation in the MEDIA strand of Creative Europe.",null,0]
["MKRS","Maintain the frequency of Implementation and Monitoring Council (IMC) meetings and identify joint solutions to be reached between Kosovo and the Serbian Orthodox Church on the basis of good will and cooperation.",null,0]
["MKRS","Continue efforts to gAIrantee that appropriate collective licensing agreements are enforced, in order to gAIrantee a remuneration for right holders (Q4 2022).",null,0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0.17,"d":"17%"}]
["Total score",null,null,2]
["Ministry of Local Government Administration"]
["MAPL","N/A","Concept document for the Law on the Commissioning and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","The draft law on the amendment of the Law on the Provision for Utilization and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","The draft law to complete the amendment of the Law on Inter-municipal Cooperation, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","AI for open local administration, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","Ex-post evalAItion of legislation on local democracy mechanisms, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","The membership of the Republic of Kosovo and municipalities in the Partnership for Open Government, approved",0]
["MAPL","N/A","The state platform eKomunat (eMunicipalities), operationalized",0]
["MAPL","N/A","Placement of eKiosks in 20 municipalities that do not have financial capacity",0]
["Percentage",null,null,{"v":0,"d":"0%"}]
["Total score",null,null,0]
[]
["Each measure is assesed along all criterias with either value \"1\" or value \"0\". Value \"1\" represents positive assessment, whilst \"0\" negative one.\n\nFor this assessment we firstly determine the clear and measurable requirements as identified in Country Report and SAA Sub-Committee conclusions. Secondly, we assess if the planned measures in NPEI and ERA address identified EU requirements. Finaly, we subtract the number of addressed requirements from the total number of EU requirements. Final scoring is graded as following: \n\n1. Higher than 0% = 1\n2. Higher than 10% = 2\n3. Higher than 20% = 3\n4. Higher than 30% = 4\n5. Higher than 40% = 5\n6. Higher than 50% = 6\n7. Higher than 60% = 7\n8. Higher than 70% = 8\n9. Higher than 80% = 9\n10. Higher than 90% = 10\n\nThis score is then transferred to the overall sheet under column “Planning vs EU obligations” criteria."]

{"sheet":"Criteria 3","index":3,"n_rows":311,"n_cols":6,"rows_kept":311,"merged":[[0,0,0,5],[2,0,2,5],[16,0,16,2],[17,0,17,2],[18,0,18,5],[55,0,55,2],[56,0,56,2],[57,0,57,5],[96,0,96,2],[97,0,97,2],[98,0,98,5],[106,0,106,2],[107,0,107,2],[108,0,108,5],[156,0,156,2],[157,0,157,2],[158,0,158,5],[197,0,197,2],[198,0,198,2],[199,0,199,5],[206,0,206,2],[207,0,207,2],[208,0,208,5],[247,0,247,2],[248,0,248,2],[249,0,249,5],[254,0,254,2],[255,0,255,2],[256,0,256,5],[269,0,269,2],[270,0,270,2],[271,0,271,5],[289,0,289,2],[290,0,290,2],[291,0,291,5],[296,0,296,2],[297,0,297,2],[298,0,298,5],[307,0,307,2],[308,0,308,2],[310,0,310,5]]}
["Criteria 3: Implementation rate\nPurpose of this assesment is to measure the implementation of measures as planed in the National Program for European Integration and European Reform Agenda Action Plan. "]
["Institution","Priority","Measure","Deadline","Reference","Implementation rate"]
["Ministry of Economy"]
["ME",null,"The draft law on Energy, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ME",null,"The draft law on the energy regulator, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ME",null,"The draft law on renewable energy sources, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q4 2022)",1]
["ME",null,"Energy Strategy Implementation Program, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q2 2022)",1]
["ME",null,"Energy and Climate Plan 2021-2030, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Regulation for the new support scheme for BRE","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Designing the competitive scheme for BRE","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Opening of the energy market for consumers of voltage level 35 kv and 10 kv","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"The completed-amended draft law on public enterprises, based on EU recommendations and good practices, was approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Bylaws approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Code of ethics and corporate governance of public enterprises, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",0]
["ME",null,"Digital Agenda for Kosovo 2030, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["ME",null,"Twenty (20) mobile network stacks, '5G ready', connected to fixed broadband infrastructure","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.46,"d":"46%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},5]
["Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Infrastructure"]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on Road Transport, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","AI for checking the technical regularity of vehicles on the road, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",0]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","The 2023-2025 action plan for the implementation of the 2023-2030 multimodal transport strategy, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","Concept document for railways, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MMPHI","Q14: Politikat e Transportit","Concept document for the transport of dangerous goods, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","The draft law to supplement and amend the Law on Strategic Environmental Assessment, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MMPHI","Q27: Mjedisi","The draft law on climate change, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Draft law on inspection in the field of environment, water, nature, spatial planning, construction and housing, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"AI for packaging and packaging waste, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Strategy for Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development 2022-2030, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
[null,null,"Kosovo State Water Strategy 2023-2027 and Action Plan 2023-2025 for its implementation, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Concept document for the water field, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Concept document for the field of nature protection, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Construction and demolition waste management plan, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Number of inspectors trained to control the implementation of environmental legislation","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Number of new nature areas (about 10), protected","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Number of illegal landfills in municipalities identified and reduced","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Greenhouse gas inventory for 2021, prepared","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"The draft law on the protection of air from pollution, approved","Q1 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"The draft law on Kosovo's waters, approved","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Waste Bill, approved","Q2 2021","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Beginning of decarbonization strategy design","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Revised National Air QAIlity Plan approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Plan for waste management with VSM in the area of Prishtina, i\ndrafted","Q2 2023","ERA",1]
[null,null,"The management plan for the Drini i Bardhë river basin, finalized","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Underground water monitoring network, operationalized","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Training at the municipal level for the implementation of legislation for the management of waste","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Training at the municipal level for the implementation of legislation for the management of waste","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Starting the implementation of waste management projects\nhazardous: facility for temporary storage of hazardous waste,\ndecommissioning of Kosovo A","Q3 2021","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Transfer and recycling centers in Skenderaj, Klina, Istog, Novobërdë, built ","Q2 2023","ERA",0]
[null,null,"The beginning of the creation of the deposit return system for bottles, plastic\nand cans","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Supplement-amendment of Law no. 03/L-233 on the protection of nature","Q3 2021","ERA",0]
[null,null,"Monitoring and reporting on the state of protected areas and biodiversity","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Spatial plan for the \"Sharri\" national park, approved","Q2 2023","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Spatial plan of the national park \"Bjeshket e Nemuna\", approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
[null,null,"Creation of the online Environmental Information System","Q1 2023","ERA",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.72,"d":"72%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
["Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and Innovation"]
["MASHTI","Q3: E drejta e themelimit dhe liria e ofrimit të shërbimeve","AI for the completion-amendment of the AI for the Standards and Procedures of Verification of the Standards of the Profession, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
[null,null,"Support of learning centers for Roma, Ashkali and Egyptians","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Scholarships for Roma, Ashkali and Egyptian pupils and students, allocated","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"National Science Program, designed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"The KRIS platform, finalized and launched","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"National contact points for the Horizon Programme, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"Core curriculum for early childhood education, designed and approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
[null,null,"Curricular framework for AAP, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
[null,null,"Adapted infrastructure (slopes) in 14 schools, inside and outside the facility","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
[null,null,"20 new Inspectors, recruited","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["Raportet për 400 mësimdhënës dhe 30 institucione arsimore për nivelin e performancës së arritur, të hartAIra","Raportet për 400 mësimdhënës dhe 30 institucione arsimore për nivelin e performancës së arritur, të hartAIra","Reports for 400 teachers and 30 educational institutions on the level of performance achieved, drawn up","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["Roli i koordinatorëve të cilësisë i definAIr përmes miratimit të AI","Roli i koordinatorëve të cilësisë i definAIr përmes miratimit të AI","The role of qauIlity coordinators defined through the approval of the AI","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Të gjitha shkollat kanë koordinator të cilësisë të trajnAIr dhe që dedikojnë numër të caktAIr të orëve për çështje të cilësisë","Të gjitha shkollat kanë koordinator të cilësisë të trajnAIr dhe që dedikojnë numër të caktAIr të orëve për çështje të cilësisë","All schools have trained qAIlity coordinators who dedicate a certain number of hours to qAIlity issues","Q1 2023","ERA",1]
["Standardet për monitorim të miratAIra","Standardet për monitorim të miratAIra","Approved monitoring standards","Q3 2021","ERA",1]
["Miratimi i politikave (rregulloreve) për sigurim të brendshëm të cilësisë","Miratimi i politikave (rregulloreve) për sigurim të brendshëm të cilësisë","Approval of policies (regulations) for internal quality assurance","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["Planit Strategjik i AKA-së, i miratAIr","Planit Strategjik i AKA-së, i miratAIr","KAA Strategic Plan, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["Njëzetepesë (25) inspektorë të rinj të arsimit, të rekrutAIr përmes procesit konkurrues","Njëzetepesë (25) inspektorë të rinj të arsimit, të rekrutAIr përmes procesit konkurrues","Twenty-five (25) new education inspectors, recruited through the competitive process","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["Pesëmbëdhjetë (15) programe të zhvillimit profesional të mësimdhënësve, të miratAIra","Pesëmbëdhjetë (15) programe të zhvillimit profesional të mësimdhënësve, të miratAIra","Fifteen (15) approved teacher professional development programs","Q1 2022","ERA",1]
["Numri i mësimdhënësve të licencAIr","Numri i mësimdhënësve të licencAIr","Number of licensed teachers","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Kurrikulat bërthamë për klasën 11 dhe 12 të zhvillAIra","Kurrikulat bërthamë për klasën 11 dhe 12 të zhvillAIra","Core curricula for grades 11 and 12, developed","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["Pakot mësimore për klasën 10, 11 dhe 12 të zhvillAIra","Pakot mësimore për klasën 10, 11 dhe 12 të zhvillAIra","Learning packages for class 10, 11 and 12, developed","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["Trajnimi i 1,500 mësimdhënësve për zbatimin e Kurrikulës bërthamë","Trajnimi i 1,500 mësimdhënësve për zbatimin e Kurrikulës bërthamë","Training of 1,500 teachers to implement the Core Curriculum","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["Projektligji për Agjencinë e Akreditimit, i miratAIr ","Projektligji për Agjencinë e Akreditimit, i miratAIr ","The draft law on the Accreditation Agency, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",1]
["Projektligji për Arsimin e Lartë, i miratAIr","Projektligji për Arsimin e Lartë, i miratAIr","The draft law on Higher Education, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["Rregullorja për organizimin e brendshëm dhe sistematizimin e vendeve të punës në MAShTI, e miratAIr","Rregullorja për organizimin e brendshëm dhe sistematizimin e vendeve të punës në MAShTI, e miratAIr","The regulation for the internal organization and systematization of workplaces in MAShTI, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",0]
["Vlerësimi i realizAIr dhe rekomandimet e përfshira në PSAK të ri","Vlerësimi i realizAIr dhe rekomandimet e përfshira në PSAK të ri","The evaluation carried out and the recommendations included in the new PSAK","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["Zbatimi i së paku 3 programeve prioritare trajnuese për secilën nga fushat e arsimit të lartë, para-universitar dhe AAP","Zbatimi i së paku 3 programeve prioritare trajnuese për secilën nga fushat e arsimit të lartë, para-universitar dhe AAP","Implementation of at least 3 priority training programs for each of the fields of higher education, pre-university and AAP","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Menaxhmenti i MAShTI-t i trajnAIr për zbatim të instrumentit të mbështetjes direkte buxhetore","Menaxhmenti i MAShTI-t i trajnAIr për zbatim të instrumentit të mbështetjes direkte buxhetore","MAShTI management trained for implementation of the direct budget support instrument","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["Menaxhmenti i MAShTI-t i trajnAIr për planifikimin dhe menaxhimin e fondeve të jashtme përfshirë menaxhimin e delegAIr","Menaxhmenti i MAShTI-t i trajnAIr për planifikimin dhe menaxhimin e fondeve të jashtme përfshirë menaxhimin e delegAIr","MAShTI management trained for planning and management of external funds, including delegated management","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["Projektligji për edukimin në fëmijërinë e hershme 0-6 vjeç, i miratAIr","Projektligji për edukimin në fëmijërinë e hershme 0-6 vjeç, i miratAIr","The draft law on early childhood education 0-6 years, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["AI për detyrat, përgjegjësitë, procedurat dhe kriteret e zgjedhjes së drejtorit dhe të zëvendësdrejtorit të institucionit edukativo-arsimor dhe aftësues para-universitar me përfshirje të aspekteve gjinore, i miratAIr","AI për detyrat, përgjegjësitë, procedurat dhe kriteret e zgjedhjes së drejtorit dhe të zëvendësdrejtorit të institucionit edukativo-arsimor dhe aftësues para-universitar me përfshirje të aspekteve gjinore, i miratAIr","AI on the duties, responsibilities, procedures and criteria for selecting the director and deputy director of the pre-university educational and training institution with inclusion of gender aspects, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1]
["AI për Procedurat e përzgjedhjes së personelit edukativo-arsimor në institucionet edukativo-arsimore dhe aftësuese (IEAA) të arsimit para-universitar me përfshirje të aspekteve gjinore, i miratAIr","AI për Procedurat e përzgjedhjes së personelit edukativo-arsimor në institucionet edukativo-arsimore dhe aftësuese (IEAA) të arsimit para-universitar me përfshirje të aspekteve gjinore, i miratAIr","AI on Procedures for the selection of educational personnel in educational and training institutions (IEAA) of pre-university education with inclusion of gender aspects, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1]
["Takime informuese në të gjitha DKA-të, të realizAIra","Takime informuese në të gjitha DKA-të, të realizAIra","Information meetings in all DKAs, carried out","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Trajnime me stafin e 6 qendrave burimore, trajnime me edukatoret e nivelit parashkollor, para-fillor si dhe mësimdhënësit e shkollave fillore, të mesme të ulëta dhe të larta","Trajnime me stafin e 6 qendrave burimore, trajnime me edukatoret e nivelit parashkollor, para-fillor si dhe mësimdhënësit e shkollave fillore, të mesme të ulëta dhe të larta","Trainings with the staff of 6 resource centers, trainings with pre-school, pre-primary level educators as well as primary, lower and upper secondary school teachers","Q3 2022","ERA",1]
["Trajnimi i institucioneve dhe ekipeve vlerësuese komunale dhe parashkollore për përdorim të instrumenteve për vlerësimin e fëmijëve me nevoja të veçanta","Trajnimi i institucioneve dhe ekipeve vlerësuese komunale dhe parashkollore për përdorim të instrumenteve për vlerësimin e fëmijëve me nevoja të veçanta","Training of municipal and preschool assessment institutions and teams for the use of instruments for the assessment of children with special needs","Q3 2022","ERA",1]
["Financimi i mjaftueshëm i qendrave ekzistuese të të mësAIrit","Financimi i mjaftueshëm i qendrave ekzistuese të të mësAIrit","Sufficient funding of existing learning centers","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["20 komuna dhe shkolla për zbatimin e platformës për parandalim dhe reagim ndaj braktisjes dhe dhunës, të mbështetura","20 komuna dhe shkolla për zbatimin e platformës për parandalim dhe reagim ndaj braktisjes dhe dhunës, të mbështetura","20 municipalities and schools for the implementation of the platform for prevention and response to abandonment and violence, supported","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Zbatimi i instruksioneve dhe udhëzuesit për themelimin dhe funksionimin e Qendrave Mësimore","Zbatimi i instruksioneve dhe udhëzuesit për themelimin dhe funksionimin e Qendrave Mësimore","Implementation of instructions and guidelines for the establishment and operation of Learning Centers","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.66,"d":"66%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},7]
["Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Development"]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The draft law on the organization of the common market of agricultural products, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The draft law on agricultural land, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","The program for agriculture and rural development 2022-2027, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MBPZHR","Perkrahja bujqesise dhe zhvillimit rural","National plan for organic agriculture, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","The draft law on veterinary medicine, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","The plan for the advancement of agro-food enterprises, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["MBPZHR","Avancimi i sigurisë së ushqimit, fitosanitarise dhe veterinarisë","Fish inventory (pilot project) in one (1) river basin, finalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.71,"d":"71%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
["Ministry of Internal Affairs"]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Draft law for supplementing and amending laws containing special administrative procedures and their harmonization with the law on general administrative procedure, second phase, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","At least 50 new services on the eKosova platform, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","The ARIS system and the Central System for Civil Registration, functionalized and interconnected","Q2 2023","ERA",0]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","At least 20% of existing draft laws, draft laws, by-laws and administrative instructions that contain special administrative procedures and are part of the legislative program, harmonized with LPPA","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","The third phase of digitization of scanned books, namely data verification and data linkage/matching, implemented","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Providing civil status services in the northern municipalities","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Ofrimi i sherbimeve cilesore publike","Reviewing the legal framework and populating the central registry with all citizen data, including historical data, reducing cases of undocumented persons","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","The draft law to supplement and amend the Law on the Organization and Functioning of the State Administration and Independent Agencies, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Digital platform for reporting on the implementation of the RAP strategic framework, functionalized","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Six (6) regulations for the implementation of the Law on Public Officials, completed-amended","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Explanatory memorandum for the law on administrative inspection, drafted","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["MPB","Krijimi i administrates Evropiane publike","Draft law on administrative inspection, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","The draft law for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q1 2023)",0]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","The draft law for the second wave of rationalization of agencies, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Concept document for the third wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q3 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Draft document for the fourth wave of agency rationalization, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["MPB","Racionalizimi i agjencive","Agency Rationalization Plan, Revised","Q2 2023","NPEI",0]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least thirty-four (34) of the thirty-eight (38) local action plans for reintegration, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","The informative circular for the implementation of policies for sustainable reintegration, drafted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Guidelines for monitoring the integration of foreigners, drafted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Extended Migration Profile 2018-2022, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Easy Migration Profile 2022, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Training of trainers (TT) with the participation of at least ten (10) central and local level officials, for the integration of foreigners, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least five (5) trainings, for 400 officials at the central and local level, for the implementation of policies for the reintegration and integration of foreigners, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least two (2) officials in the Temporary Reception Center, systematized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least 60 women or girls benefiting from reintegration and sustainable integration schemes","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Draft law on citizenship, supplemented-amended","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","The draft law to supplement - amend the Law on Foreigners, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","At least three (3) trainings within the EAIA cooperation roadmap, with the participation of at least three (3) asylum officials, organized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Zbatimi i politikave efektive te migrimit","Draft law on housing and residences, completed-amended","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","IT program, with QlikView option, to include Case Management System (CMS) and Border Intelligence (BI) Platform, advanced","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","Interconnection of the NjIP, with at least three (3) operators to receive REU data, operationalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on the Control and Supervision of the State Border, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Avancimi i menaxhimit te integrAIr te kuijve","The action plan of the QKMK, fully implemented","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Department for Intelligence and Analysis in KP, established","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least twenty (20) analysts trained in the field of analysis","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least 200 sector police (neighborhood police), assigned","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The Special Investigations Unit in KP, established in accordance with the Law on Special Prosecution","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","At least two (2) joint police-prosecutor trainings, for at least ten (10) police officers, for financial investigations, confiscation of assets and effective protection of witnesses, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Liaison officer with EUROPOL, organized","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","Participation in at least four (4) activities within EMPACT","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The draft law for supplementing - amending the Gun Law, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","AI for Joint Investigation Teams, approved","Q3 2021","ERA",0]
["MPB","Luftimi i krimit të organizAIr dhe bashkëpunimi policor","The Joint Plan between the Kosovo Police and GAIrdia di Finanza, drawn up","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["MPB","Lufta kunder terrorizmit","The six-monthly reports on the implementation of the EU-Western Balkans Joint Action Plan against Violent Extremism and Terrorism, drawn up","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Lufta kunder terrorizmit","TeSAT report for EUROPOL, compiled","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MPB","Lufta kunder terrorizmit","Strategy for the prevention of terrorism and violent extremism, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.77,"d":"77%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
["Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade"]
["MINT",null,"Regulation for supplementing - amending Regulation (MINT) no. 01/2018 on Labeling and Marking of Textile Products, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Decision on the publication of the list of titles and references of harmonized standards for electrical equipment intended for use within certain voltage limits, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Decision on the publication of the list of titles and references of harmonized standards for electromagnetic compatibility, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Concept document for the field of accreditation, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"Business Information Unit, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Accreditation Scheme for certification bodies (EN ISO/IEC 17065), established and functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Laboratory of strength and thermometry, accredited","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"At least ten (10) new officials in the market inspectorate, recruited","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"At least five (5) new officials in AMK, recruited","Q2 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"At least ten (10) trained product safety officers","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"EN ISO/IEC 17020 standard for legal metrology laboratories (mass laboratory, flow volume laboratory, electrical measurement laboratory and pressure laboratory), implemented","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"AI for biofuels, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"The online system for the sale of standards, functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"The draft law on the register of beneficial owners, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"The draft law on commercial companies, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"At least two (2) new service sectors, digitized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Website for single point of contact, created and launched","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Strategy for industry development and business support, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Agency for the support of enterprises, established and functionalized","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"Analysis of the impact of economic zones on the development of SMEs, carried out","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"At least forty (40) businesses benefiting from grants that help businesses to increase production capacity and implement the standards required in the EU market","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"At least 20 businesses (10 until Q2 2022 and 10 until Q2 2023) subsidized in the form of grants for product certification","Q2 2023","ERA",1]
["MINT",null,"The organizational structure of KIESA approved which addresses the main aspects of performance improvement: the division of responsibilities, financial resources and human capacities","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"Complaint mechanism, established","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"Care program, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"Investor Care Unit, established","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"Performance evalAItion of support schemes for KIESA businesses, carried out","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"Accreditation Scheme for certification bodies (EN ISO/IEC 17065) established and functionalized","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"At least two (2) officials recruited to the Metrology Agency","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"At least one (1) new laboratory in the Metrology Agency established","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["MINT",null,"Unit for informing businesses about standards, established","Q4 2022","ERA",1]
["MINT",null,"Single point of contact, established and functionalized","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MINT",null,"AI on the requirements defined in relation to commercial communication, including advertising or marketing, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Program for industrial ownership, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"At least three (3) trainings for the officials of the Industrial Property Agency, carried out","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"At least one (1) product registered according to the geographical indication","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MINT",null,"Trade policy document, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MINT",null,"One (1) official in the Department of Trade, recruited","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.61,"d":"61%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},7]
["Ministry of Justice"]
["MD","Avancimi i luftes kunder korrupsioni","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on the Administration of Seized and Confiscated Property, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","The agreement for legal cooperation with France was signed","Q3 2023","NPEI",0]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","Concept document for the realization of civil rights, including the right of the parties to a trial within a reasonable time, approved","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","The draft law on administrative disputes, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","Concept Document for the realization of civil rights, including the right of the parties to trial within a reasonable time","Q4 2023","ERA",1]
["MD","Sigurimi i drejtave themelore te qytetareve","The draft law on prevention and protection from domestic violence and gender-based violence, approved","Q4 2023","ERA",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.67,"d":"67%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},7]
["Ministry of Finance, Labor and Transfers"]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","The number of trainings held for the Macro Department at MFLT and the Unit for Monitoring of PEs in ME through the IMF-FAD regional technical assistance project funded by the EU","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Regular six-monthly reporting of the implementation of the SMFP Action Plan 2022-2024","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Regular annAIl reporting of the implementation of the SMFP Action Plan 2022-2024","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","Drafting the analysis of fiscal risks, including the risks coming from PEs, included in the macro-fiscal framework, in strategic documents such as KASh, budget law and PRE","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Ekzistenca e ekonomisë funksionale të tregut","QAIrterly financial and performance reports for all NPs, prepared","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Youth GAIrantee Scheme Implementation Plan, piloted","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of women involved in the active measures of the labor market, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of labor inspectors increased by 100 additional inspectors","Q4 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q4 2022)",1]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The number of inspections by the Labor Inspectorate, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Craft Grant Scheme","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The draft law on the social assistance scheme, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The draft law on safety and health at work, drafted and approved","Q2 2021","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","Labor draft law, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The Information Technology System of the Labor Inspectorate, established","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Krijimi i vendeve te reja pune dhe mbrojtja sociale e qytetareve ","The state program for encouraging investments in energy efficiency by subsidizing households and businesses that invest in this area, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","The draft law on payment services, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Draft document on preventing money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Guidelines for risk factors, developed and approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Memorandum of understanding for compliance supervision between FIAInd CBK, signed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","At least two (2) supervised mentoring activities, developed","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Increased number of suspicious transaction/activity reports received","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Lëvizja e lirë e kapitalit","Methodologies for risk assessment, revised/drafted","Q3 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Project - code for completion - amendment of the Customs and Excise Code in Kosovo, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Combating the informal economy and customs fraud through increased cooperation and coordination between Customs, law enforcement agencies and other relevant institutions, measured by the number of inspections carried out, the number of operations undertaken, the results achieved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Moving to public property and fully operationalizing at least one (1) customs terminal","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Draft document for the review of tax policies, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",0]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","The number of activities within projects to improve tax compliance, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Number of risk-based compliance checks and visits, increased","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Politikat e favorshme tatimore dhe doganore","Number of actions taken to improve tax compliance","Q2 2023","ERA",1]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Draft law for supplementing - amending the Law on Public Procurement, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q1 2022)",0]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","The draft law on the amendment of the Law on the Auditor General and the National Audit Office of Kosovo, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",0]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Internal audit committees in all budget organizations, including the municipal level, established","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MFPT","Prokurimi publik dhe kontrolli financiar","Concept Document for the establishment of an independent fiscal body approved after consultation with stakeholders including the EU","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Fifty (50) information sessions for municipalities, line ministries, regulatory and justice institutions","Q2 2023","ERA",1]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Number of schemes harmonized with State Aid Rules","Q1 2023","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","State aid draft law, revised","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Regulation on Horizontal Aid, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MFPT","Ndihma shtetërore, ne harmoni me rregullat e BE-se","Number of additional schemes notified in DNSH","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.63,"d":"63%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},7]
["Ministry of Communities and Returns"]
["MKK",null,"The strategy for the protection and promotion of the rights of communities and their members, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MKK",null,"Up to 56 displaced and socially vulnerable people in the Municipality of Graçanica, organized in permanent housing units","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MKK",null,"Five (5) meetings at the municipal level, according to regions, for the implementation of the Strategy for the Protection and Promotion of the Rights of Communities and their Members, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MKK",null,"Inter-Ministerial Coordinating Group for Durable Solutions for Displaced Persons established","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.75,"d":"75%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
["Ministry of Health"]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on measures to prevent the abuse of narcotic and psychotropic substances for children, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on measures for medical, psychological assistance, rehabilitation and reintegration of child victims of abuse, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","AI on the combined remarks on the tobacco packaging unit, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","List and price list of health services, drawn up","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MSH","Mbrojtja e shëndetit","The draft law for the prevention and control of infectious diseases, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",1]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The health sector strategy 2022-2032, drafted","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The draft law for health insurance, approved","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","The draft law for health, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for the implementation of exemption from the payment of premiums, co-payments and co-financing for health services, drafted","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for out-of-hospital drug scheme, drafted","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","AI for medical treatment outside public health institutions, completed-amended","Q1 2022","ERA",0]
["MSH","Forcimi i funksioneve kyçe të sistemit shëndetësor","Feasibility study for SISh, completed","Q4 2021","ERA",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.42,"d":"42%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},5]
["Office of the Prime Minister"]
["ZKM","Krijimi i administrates efektive publike","The annual report on the evaluation of the performance of executive agencies, drafted","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Krijimi i administrates efektive publike","The final report on the performance of the executive agencies, approved by the Government","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Promovimi i lirive fetare","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on Religious Freedom in Kosovo, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q3 2022)",1]
["ZKM","Promovimi i lirive fetare","By-laws within the framework of the law on religious freedoms, drafted and approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","Number of implemented recommendations of the Ombudsman","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","The number of responses received from the responsible institutions regarding the recommendations addressed to the Ombudsman","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Zbatimi i rekomandimeve te Avokatit te Popullit","Raising to at least 60% the implementation of the recommendations of the  Ombudsman and 95% providing answers to the addressed recommendations within the legal deadline","Q4 2021","ERA",0]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te njeriut","Human rights indicator framework developed","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","The National Plan for Gender EqAIlity 2023-2026, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Sixteen (16) AI derived from the child protection law, approved","Q2 2022","ERA",0]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Raising public awareness of the prevention of violence against women, combating gender stereotypes, and the rights gAIranteed by the legal framework for gender eqAIlity by preparing five (5) videos and three (3) roundtable discussions","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","AI (affirmative measure) for the registration of joint immovable property in the name of two spouses, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Sub-legal act on the implementation of gender budgeting, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Affirmative measures to increase the number of women in decision-making positions - executive level, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","Support of 10 NGOs that aim to strengthen the role of women in society","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Avancimi i drejtave te grave dhe femijeve","At least ten (10) trainings on advancing the realization of inheritance rights; decision making; peace, security and justice, held","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["ZKM","Krijimi i nje mjedisi te lire per media","The draft law for supplementing and amending the Law on the Independent Media Commission, approved","Q2 2023","NPEI\nERA (Q2 2021)",1]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.71,"d":"71%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
["Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports"]
["MKRS","Mbrojtja efektive e pronësisë intelektAIle","AI on procedures, conditions for licensing of collective management organizations, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MKRS","Mbrojtja efektive e pronësisë intelektAIle","At least one (1) Association for Collective Management in the field of literature, licensed","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["MKRS","Përmirësimi i zbatimit të të drejtave dhe lirive themelore","The draft law on cultural heritage, approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["MKRS","Përmirësimi i zbatimit të të drejtave dhe lirive themelore","By-laws in the framework of the advancement of cultural heritage protection, drafted and approved","Q4 2022","ERA",0]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.25,"d":"25%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},3]
["Ministry of Local Government Administration"]
["MAPL",null,"Draft document for the Law on the Commissioning and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved","Q1 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"The draft law on supplementing and amending the Law on the Use and Exchange of Municipal Immovable Property, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"The draft law to complete the amendment of the Law on Inter-municipal Cooperation, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["MAPL",null,"AI for open local administration, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"Ex-post evalAItion of legislation on local democracy mechanisms, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"The membership of the Republic of Kosovo and municipalities in the Partnership for Open Government, approved","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"The state platform eKomunat (eMunicipalities), functionalized","Q4 2023","NPEI",1]
["MAPL",null,"Placement of eKiosks in 20 municipalities that do not have financial capacity","Q4 2023","NPEI",0]
["Percentage",{"$nulls":4},{"v":0.75,"d":"75%"}]
["Total score",{"$nulls":4},8]
[]
["Each measure is assesed along all criterias with either value \"1\" or value \"0\". Value \"1\" represents positive assessment: meaning that the measure has been implemented, value \"0\" a negative one: meaning that the measure has not been implemented.\n\nFor this criterion we count how many measures were completed during the reporting period compared to the total of measures that were planned. \nFinal scoring is graded as following: \n\n1. Higher than 0% = 1\n2. Higher than 10% = 2\n3. Higher than 20% = 3\n4. Higher than 30% = 4\n5. Higher than 40% = 5\n6. Higher than 50% = 6\n7. Higher than 60% = 7\n8. Higher than 70% = 8\n9. Higher than 80% = 9\n10. Higher than 90% = 10\n\nThis score is then transferred to the overall sheet under column “Implementation rate” criteria. "]

{"sheet":"Criteria 4","index":4,"n_rows":62,"n_cols":3,"rows_kept":62,"merged":[[0,0,0,2],[2,0,2,2],[5,0,5,1],[6,0,6,2],[9,0,9,1],[10,0,10,2],[14,0,14,1],[15,0,15,2],[18,0,18,1],[19,0,19,2],[22,0,22,1],[23,0,23,2],[32,0,32,1],[33,0,33,2],[35,0,35,1],[36,0,36,2],[42,0,42,1],[43,0,43,2],[45,0,45,1],[46,0,46,2],[48,0,48,1],[49,0,49,2],[52,0,52,1],[53,0,53,2],[56,0,56,1],[57,0,57,2],[59,0,59,1],[61,0,61,2]]}
["Criteria 3: Implementation rate\nEach year European Commission publishes annAIl country report for Kosovo. In the report EC uses qAIntifiable methodology that allows measurement of country's annAIl progress in adopting obligations of EU membership according to the following description: (0) backsliding; (1) no progress; (2) limited progress; (3) some progress; (4) good progress; (5) very good progress. Purpose of this assessment is to factor in the progress that each line ministry has done during the assessment period."]
["Institution","EU country report chapter","EU country report assessment"]
["Ministry of Economy"]
["ME","Chapter 15: Energy",10]
["ME","Chapter 10: Digital transformation and media",-10]
["Score",null,10]
["Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Infrastructure"]
["MMPHI","Chapter 14: Transport policy",-10]
["MMPHI","Chapter 27: Environment and climate change",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Education, Science, Technology and Innovation"]
["MASHTI","Chapter 3: Right of establishment and freedom to provide services",0]
["MASHTI","Chapter 25: Science and research",10]
["MASHTI","Chapter 26: Education and culture",0]
["Score",null,10]
["Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Development"]
["MBPZHR","Chapter 11: Agriculture and rural development ",0]
["MBPZHR","Chapter 12: Food safety, veterinary and phytosanitary policy",-10]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Internal Affairs"]
["MPB","Public administration reform",0]
["MPB","Chapter 24: Justice, freedom and security",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade"]
["MINT","Chapter 1: Free movement of goods",0]
["MINT","Chapter 2: Freedom of movement for workers\nChapter 3: Right of establishment and freedom to provide services",-10]
["MINT","Chapter 4: Free movement of capital ",0]
["MINT","Chapter 6: Company law ",0]
["MINT","Chapter 7: IntellectAIl property law",0]
["MINT","Chapter 20: Enterprise and industrial policy",10]
["MINT","Chapter 28: Consumer and health protection",0]
["MINT","Chapter 30: External relations",0]
["Score",null,10]
["Ministry of Justice"]
["MD","Chapter 23: Judiciary and fundamental rights",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Finance, Labor and Transfers"]
["MFPT","The existence of a functioning market economy",0]
["MFPT","Chapter 16: Taxation",0]
["MFPT","Chapter 17: Economic and monetary policy ",0]
["MFPT","Chapter 19: Social policy and employment",0]
["MFPT","Chapter 29: Customs union",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Communities and Returns"]
["MKK","Chapter 23: Judiciary and fundamental rights",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Health"]
["MSH","Chapter 28: Consumer and health protection",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Office of the Prime Minister"]
["ZKM","Public administration reform",0]
["ZKM","Chapter 23: Judiciary and fundamental rights",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Culture, Youth and Sports"]
["MKRS","Chapter 7: IntellectAIl property law",0]
["MKRS","Chapter 23: Judiciary and fundamental rights",0]
["Score",null,0]
["Ministry of Local Government Administration"]
["MAPL","N/A",0]
["Score",null,0]
[]
["Differently from other criterions, under this criterion we do not assess each measure. Here the entire ministry is assessed with one of the following values: “10”, “0” or “-10”.\n\nMinistry is assessed with value “10” if latest country report has noted better progress this year than the previous one.\nMinistry is assessed with value “0” if latest country report has seen no change in the performance of the ministry this year compared to the previous one.\nMinistry is assessed with value “-10” if latest country report has noted less progress this year than the previous one.\n\nFinally, the score is then transferred to the overall sheet under column “EU Country Report Assessment” criteria. "]